VS
Otty logo banner
Eve logo banner

Otty vs Eve Mattresses

Want Mattress is supported by readers. Some links on Want Mattress are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Want Mattress may make a small amount of money. More info .

Otty

Otty is a British brand that started in 2017 and has grown quickly into one of the most recognised hybrid mattress names on the UK market. The company is based in Leeds and sells direct to the customer, cutting out the middle man in the traditional bed retail chain and passing the savings on in the form of long trial periods and sensible prices.

Their hybrid lineup pairs cooling gel infused memory foam with individually encased pocket springs, and it is the hybrid build that Otty is best known for. Every mattress ships vacuum packed in a box, and buyers get a 100 night home trial along with a 10 year guarantee.

Read our full Otty review

Eve

Eve Sleep emerged in 2014 as a prominent online retailer specializing in mattresses and sleep accessories. The company gained recognition for its clever approach to mattress design and marketing, offering a range of products aimed at improving sleep quality. In 2022, Eve Sleep was acquired by Bensons for Beds, further solidifying its position in the sleep products market.

Eve Sleep's product lineup includes various mattress types, such as memory foam and hybrid models, catering to diverse sleep preferences. In particular, the company introduced the "Wunderflip" mattress, designed to offer two levels of firmness by simply flipping it over, allowing users to customize their sleep experience.  Eve Sleep provides a 200-night trial period, enabling customers to thoroughly test their mattresses.

Read our full Eve review

Mattress Score

Overall Score:
Otty: 4.44/5.00
Eve: 4.44/5.00

Price:
Otty: £474.99 - £1249.99
Eve: £250.00 - £1699.99


Based on aggregated reviews and performance scoring, we would recommend Eve in this face off!


Becky
Compares

Otty Owner Satisfaction

Otty mattresses sit at around 4.7 out of 5 across the review sites we track, which is close to the top of the hybrid category in the UK. Most of the praise focuses on two things: the genuinely cool feel, which comes from the breathable cover and the open spring layer, and the edge support, which is noticeably firmer than most foam rivals.

Couples tend to rate Otty higher than single sleepers, because the pocket springs absorb movement well and the firm edges mean nobody rolls towards the middle. The mattress is on the firmer side of medium, so side sleepers who want a very soft feel sometimes find it a little too supportive, but for most average weight sleepers the firmness works out just right.

Otty Supportiveness

The Otty Original Hybrid uses a top layer of cooling gel memory foam over a reflex foam transition layer and a core of pocket springs. Each spring moves independently, which is why the mattress copes well with two people of different weights sleeping side by side. The foam layers add enough pressure relief for the shoulders and hips, and the spring core keeps the lower back properly supported without letting anyone sink into a hammock shape.

For heavier sleepers over about 16 stone, Otty also makes the Pure Hybrid Plus, which has a reinforced spring unit and thicker comfort layers to stop the mattress bottoming out. In both models, the support level is one of the things owners consistently pick out as a strong point.

Otty Durability

Otty uses a high gauge spring unit and good quality foams above it, which is the right recipe for a mattress that holds its shape over the long run. The cover is removable and washable, which is unusual at this level of the market and helps the mattress stay fresh over the years.

Long term owners we have spoken to report very little sagging at the three and four year mark, and the 10 year guarantee gives a clear signal of how much life the brand expects out of its own product. Given the materials and the build, Otty mattresses are well positioned to last the seven to ten years that most buyers are looking for.

Otty Best Offers

We've managed to find the following top deals from across the web on Otty mattresses.

    Eve Owner Satisfaction

    Satisfaction with Eve Sleep mattresses remains high, with a solid score at the time of writing. Many owners praise the balanced comfort and support, particularly in the brand’s hybrid models, which combine foam and pocket springs for a responsive yet cushioned feel. Unlike some all-foam mattresses, Eve’s construction helps to minimise heat retention, with breathable layers designed to promote airflow throughout the night. That said, a handful of users have noted that the firmer models can take some getting used to, especially for those accustomed to softer sleep surfaces.

    When it comes to pressure relief and spinal alignment, Eve mattresses generally receive positive feedback, particularly from those with back issues. The medium-firm options tend to provide good lumbar support, while the softer models cater well to side sleepers who need more contouring. However, some users have mentioned that edge support isn’t as strong as they’d like, meaning there can be a slight dip when sitting on the side of the bed. Despite this, the overall consensus is that Eve Sleep delivers a well-balanced sleeping experience, blending comfort and support in a way that suits a wide range of sleepers.

    Eve Supportiveness

    Eve Sleep mattresses are renowned for their exceptional support, attributed to the innovative use of high-quality foams and, in their hybrid models, full-sized pocket springs. The Original Hybrid Mattress, for instance, features over 800 individually wrapped 12 cm springs that respond to the body's movements, providing targeted pressure relief for the shoulders and hips. These springs are complemented by Eve's proprietary evecomfort® foam layer, which offers a springy feel to support key pressure points and maintain spinal alignment. This combination ensures a harmonious balance of support and body contouring, catering to various sleeping positions.

    Eve Durability

    Eve Sleep mattresses feature polyester covers, known for their soft, stretchy, and breathable finish. This type of cover provides a reasonable level of durable protection, contributing to the overall longevity of the mattress. User feedback indicates general satisfaction with the expected lifespan, and while the Eve lineup is relatively new, the bed-in-a-box mattress market has established a reputation for durability comparable to traditional mattresses. Considering that the average mattress lasts about 7 years, we have no concerns regarding the performance and durability of the current Eve lineup.

    Eve Best Offers

    We've managed to find the following top deals from across the web on Eve mattresses.

    Otty Most Useful Customer Reviews

    4 Verified Buyer

    The plush comfort yet firm support is really impressive. It must be due to the mixed layers of wool, silk, and cashmere along with the firm pocket-spring core. Truly, it is a good balance.

    5 Aliceee

    Really comfortable and noticeably cooler than my last mattress, definite improvement in my sleep quality. Unboxing was easy and it expanded to full size quickly.

    4 Verified Buyer

    Felt a marked improvement in sleep quality due to the firm yet comfy feel of this mattress. Especially appreciated how it stayed cool throughout warmer nights.

    5 Sean A

    Really good product. It's made a difference to my sleep, no more waking up with a sore back. Comfortable yet very supportive. It's great value for money.

    4 Verified Reviewer

    Enjoying the blend of traditional craftsmanship and innovative design. The mattress is firm yet gently cushioning and I've noticed a much cooler sleep.

    Eve Most Useful Customer Reviews

    5 Gaynor W

    We absolutely love this mattress as it's so comfortable. It feels really firm when you first get into bed, like it's just to hard, but as it warms with your body heat it softens where you are lying, making it really comfortable. Great for a bad back or anyone who like a firmer bed. The only downside is our fitted sheets slide and bunch up through the night and even having bought some elasticated bed clips it's still an issue. Not sure if taking the removable cover off and just using a mattress protector would better? Either way it doesn't detract much from it being the best mattress we've ever had and at the price was considerably cheaper than our last one, making it excellent value for money too. All in all I would definitely recommend it for anyone needing a firm mattress or anyone with back issues. We sleep so well that I wish we'd bought it earlier, but are very happy to have it now.

    5 Tracey W

    My daughter wanted a soft but not sinkable double mattress with her new bed. Bensons were so helpful and very patient. Eventually she settled for the Hybrid duo plus and absolutely loves it. No negatives at all, ok there is a smell to begin with but not overpowering. So we bought the same for one of our spare bedrooms. Having autoimmune arthritis I have spent years in agony lying in bed, unable to sleep on any side even considering sleeping in a lounge chair. Assuming it was my arthritis getting worse I didn't consider the mattress until I had to move into the spare due to having the master renovated, I was really apprehensive also because I need a king size as I'm constantly moving around. Well it was a revelation, I had no back pain! I'm still in the spare room and will definitely be buying one very soon but a king size unfortunately to fit my bed. 5 star comfort for me.

    5 David L

    I can't say enough good things about this mattress! From the first night, I noticed a huge difference in my sleep quality. The perfect balance of comfort and support keeps me feeling well-rested and free of aches in the morning. It contours to my body just right, without feeling too soft or too firm. Another big plus is that it stays cool throughout the night-no more overheating or tossing and turning! The materials feel high-quality, and even after weeks of use, there's no sagging or loss of support. If you're looking for a mattress that will improve your sleep and overall well-being, this is the one to get. Highly recommend!

    5 Sophie J

    I am so pleased with choosing Benson for Beds. They have been so helpful from start to finish. I had lots of updates from Bensons reminding me of when my mattress will be delivered. They turned up as scheduled and were so professional and advised me on how to take care of my new bed. I am so impressed with the quality and comfort of this mattress. It is so comfortable! I have definitely chosen the right bed for me! I have also got an ottoman bed frame from Bensons at the same time. It has so much space underneath and it looks so modern and stylish in bed bedroom. I couldn't be more happy with choosing Bensons for Beds!

    5 Aimee B

    Overall, the Evie Duo Hybrid feels really well-made and worth the money. It's comfortable, adaptable, and I wake up without aches or stiffness. Definitely one of the best mattresses I've tried! It feels super supportive around the edges, and I don't sink in too much when I sit or lie near the side. My partner moves around a lot at night, but I barely feel it. I've been sleeping on the mattress for a few weeks now, and I'm really impressed. It has the perfect mix of softness and support. It's honestly the first mattress I've had that makes me look forward to going to bed every night.

    Decorative award symbol in corner
    Mobile award badge

    Introducing our WantMattress Better-Sleep Award

    Looking for a new mattress? Our experts have tried and tested the best UK mattresses for back, side, and front sleepers from Eve, Emma, Origin, and more top brands.

    Quantitative measurements icon
    New Quantitative Measurements
    Head-to-head comparison icon
    Radar Analysis Head to Head
    Suitable for different sleeper types icon
    Who This Mattress Will Suit
    Sleep experts' approval icon
    Why our sleep experts loved it