How we test in store
Our testers lie on mattresses in the showrooms of Dreams, Bensons for Beds and Furniture Village, where a retailer's range sits side by side and you can go from one bed straight onto the next. They have tried 353 products in person, 223 mattresses and 116 beds among them, and every one names its tester on the product page.
On each mattress our tester lies on their back, then their side, then their front, and scores six things out of 5. Half points are allowed, because the difference between a 3 and a 4 is usually where the interesting bit is.
- Back sleeping: whether the hips stay level with the shoulders or sink below them
- Side sleeping: whether the shoulder and hip sink in far enough to take the pressure off
- Front sleeping: whether the hips dip, which is what bends a front sleeper's lower back
- Breathability: how warm the surface feels against you once you've lain still on it
- Turning over: how easily you can change position, or whether the mattress keeps you where you are
- Stability: how far the edge gives when you sit on it, whether you roll towards the middle, and any wobble
Those six scores replace our build-based scores on the product page and are marked as our tester's. Where owners rate the same thing a point or more differently, the page shows both figures side by side.
Our tester also writes notes: the firmness in their own words, the first thing they noticed lying down, how far the edge sinks, whether a partner turning over reaches them, and anything a sales assistant said that the listing leaves out. Those notes become the “Testing team takeaways” on the product page.
Photos from the showroom floor
Our tester photographs each mattress and bed they try on the shop floor, with the store's ticket in shot where they can get it. A showroom name and a website name don't always match, and the photo shows which one our tester lay on. We check the photos against their notes and the specification when the review is written.
Bed frames
On a bed frame, our tester scores the same things the product page does, each out of 5:
- Material: the quality of the slats, joints, fixings and fabric
- Storage space: how much the drawers or ottoman base hold, and how easy they are to reach
- Opening mechanism: on an ottoman, how smoothly the lid lifts and whether it stays up
Their notes cover how solid the frame feels when you sit and lie on it, creaks included, and how heavy it is to shift.
Occasionally a brand sends us a mattress to try at home. When it does, our tester sleeps on it for one to two weeks before writing it up, so the review covers how it feels after the first few nights as well as on the first.
Who tests
A mattress feels firmer to a lighter person and softer to a heavier one, and a side sleeper needs a different surface from a back sleeper. Our testers cover a spread of weights and sleeping positions, and each product page says which of them tested it.
| Tester | Weight | Sleeps | Products tested |
|---|
| Becky ReeveStaff Writer, Mattress Expert | 61 kg | Side sleeper | 238 |
| Ron BurnsStaff Writer, Beds and Bed Frames | 79 kg | Combination sleeper | 50 |
| Rebecca BrownStaff Writer, Family Sleep | 66 kg | Combination sleeper | 41 |
| Katie EdwardsStaff Writer, Bedding and Bed Frames | 68 kg | Back sleeper | 24 |
Each tester's profile on our about page sets out their background. Compare their weight and sleeping position with your own, and use the SnoozeScore on each mattress page (see below) to check the fit for you.
The fact file behind each review
Before we write a review, we gather everything published about the product into one fact file, and the review is written from that file. Every fact goes in with the source's own words, the web address and the date we checked it, so any claim on the page can be traced back to where it came from.
- The retailer's specification: each layer from top to bottom with its thickness, the spring type and count with the size that count is quoted for, the fillings, the depth, every firmness grade on sale and whether it arrives rolled or flat
- The maker's own pages: the spec sheet, the care guide and the guarantee clauses, down to the depth of dip the guarantee counts as a fault
- Owner reviews: the praise and the complaints, read separately for high and low ratings, with short quotes in owners' own words
- Buyer questions: what people ask on the listing and the answers they get, which tells us what the review has to answer
- Rivals: two to four mattresses you could buy instead, from the same retailer first and then the same price band and build, each with the one fact that makes it the better or worse buy
- The previous model: when this one appeared, what changed from the model it replaced, and which owner reviews were written about the older version
When two sources disagree, both go in the file in their own words, and the maker's spec sheet beats the retailer's marketing copy. A spring count quoted for a king and printed against every size is the one I see most, and the fact file is where we catch it.
How we read owner reviews
We count what owners say about each mattress, review by review, and put the counts in the Owners, by the numbers block on its product page. A star average can bury a sagging problem under a pile of happy first-week reviews. Counting is how you find it.
The counts come from owner reviews published on retailer listings. Each review counts once, even where a retailer shows it on several listings, and reviews left on WantMattress stay out of the count. Every figure in the block comes with the number of reviews behind it.
- The owner verdict: the share of owners who gave five stars and the share who gave one or two, once at least 20 owners have rated the mattress
- Firmness against the label: how many owners found it firmer or softer than expected, and how many called it too firm or too soft, set against every mattress sold with the same firmness label. It shows once 50 reviews have something to say about firmness and the label has at least 1,000 reviews of its own to compare with
- Praise and complaints: sagging or keeping its shape, sleeping hot or cool, back pain or good back support, a smell or none, and poor or good value, each set against all mattresses. A topic shows once 10 owners have mentioned it
- Price against its peers: how many other mattresses of the same build cost less today, once we track at least 10 of them
Those figures live in the block and nowhere in the review's prose, so the two never disagree. Where at least half of a mattress's reviews also appear on the retailer's other listings for that brand, the counts move up to brand level in our mattress reliability report, because they describe the range rather than one model.
The phrases we count for firmness are listed in our mattress firmness report, and the method behind the praise and complaint counts is in the reliability report.
How we track prices
We read the price of every mattress listing we follow each time we sync that retailer, and we keep every reading. Our price tracker has recorded 187,138 mattress prices for 1,859 listings across 20 UK retailers since June 2019.
Each price is judged against that listing's own median over the previous 90 days, so a sale has to beat what the mattress usually costs, not the was-price on the ticket. A was-price is a number the retailer chose. The median is one we measured.
Each product page shows how many times we've checked that mattress's price and since when. Our mattress price report sets out how often prices move and whether Black Friday is cheaper.
How we reach a verdict
We start every verdict from the build, then check it against what owners report, what the trade knows and what the rivals offer for the money. Each review says who the mattress suits, who should buy something else, and the drawbacks as well as the advantages.
The build. Layers, springs, fillings and depth tell you most of what a mattress will feel like and how it will wear, before anyone lies on it. Two mattresses can sit at the same price with very different insides, and the build is how we tell them apart.
The test. Where our tester has scored the mattress, what they found leads the review, in the past tense, with the month of the test.
The owners. Then we check the build against the owner reviews. If the spec says firm support and owners keep reporting a dip down the middle, we side with the owners.
The trade view. Our team has over 10 years in the mattress industry, so we know how each construction tends to wear and which label words promise more than the build behind them. “Orthopaedic” is my favourite example, and nobody printing it has ever told me what it means.
Value against named rivals. Last, we weigh the price against the rivals in the fact file. The review names the one we'd buy instead and links to it, so you can check our reasoning on its own page.
How the scores work
Every product page carries several scores.
Review rating
Our rating is our editorial score out of 10. It shows on every product page and listing as a navy chip, with how we reached it underneath (tested in store, tested at home, or assessed by our team). The owner rating sits beside it as a separate figure out of 5, marked with a gold star: the average of the owner reviews we hold for that product.
The rating is our team's overall assessment of a product, reached the way How we reach a verdict describes. Where we have tested a product, what the tester found carries the most weight.
The Review Rating is our team's verdict on a product after weighing the evidence: one number for the whole product. It is an editorial judgement, not an automated calculation.
Performance indicators
Beyond the overall rating, each product is scored on a set of specific questions, grouped under headings such as Suitability and Performance. A question might be how well a mattress supports a side sleeper, or how much of a partner's movement it absorbs.
Each question is scored out of 5, in half points, and shown as a bar with its score beside it. Where our tester has scored a mattress, their score is the one you see. Otherwise the score starts from the build, and on mattresses with enough owner reviews it moves with what owners report about firmness, back support, heat, smell and durability, by no more than a point either way. On the product page, click any metric to see what it measures.
What the Performance Indicator scores draw on:
- Our tester's scores, where we have tested the product
- Manufacturer specifications and materials data
- Patterns across owner reviews
- Our experience of the product or of similar ones
The Suitability scores assume an average body weight. How firm a mattress feels depends on your weight, so check the SnoozeScore (below) as well.
Radar analysis
Our Radar Analysis chart scores the whole purchase, not only the mattress. It plots six measures on a radar chart and compares each against a baseline for the UK mattress market.
The six axes are:
- Retailer (baseline: 80/100): overall retailer quality, including customer service, the returns process and trustworthiness
- Brand (baseline: 80/100): the brand's reputation, track record and standing in the industry
- Guarantee (baseline: 20/100): the quality of the warranty or guarantee. The baseline is low because many mattresses come with only a minimal guarantee
- Sentiment (baseline: 70/100): customer sentiment drawn from owner reviews on retailer sites
- Delivery Charge (baseline: 80/100): how the delivery cost compares with the market average
- Delivery Time (baseline: 60/100): delivery speed compared with the industry norm
Each axis is scored on a 0–100 scale. Scores below 80 are rated Average, scores from 80 to 99 are rated Good, and 100 is rated Excellent. The baseline is drawn on the chart: where the product's line sits outside it, the product beats the market on that measure, and where it sits inside, it falls short.
Radar Analysis covers the purchase as a whole, from the brand's reputation to how quickly the mattress arrives.
Personalised suitability
SnoozeScore asks you six questions and turns your answers into the firmness we'd start you on. The same six run on Find my mattress and on every mattress product page. Each mattress here has a firmness rating from soft to extra firm, but a mattress rated medium can feel firm to one person and soft to another, so your answers come first.
- How you sleep: side sleepers start at medium, so the shoulder and hip can sink in while the spine stays level. Back sleepers and people who change position start at medium-firm, and front sleepers at firm, because a soft mattress lets the hips sag.
- What you weigh: under 9 stone (57 kg) moves you one step softer and over 18 stone (114 kg) one step firmer, since a heavier body sinks further into the same mattress.
- Aches or pain: with back, neck, shoulder or hip pain we keep you between medium and medium-firm, never firm. In a Lancet trial of 313 adults with long-term lower back pain, the medium-firm group did better than the firm group. The trials only cover lower back pain, so for the neck, shoulder or hip that band is our rule of thumb.
- Sleeping hot: if you wake up warm, we look for mattresses on our hot-sleeper shortlist.
- Who sleeps on it: if you share the bed, we look for mattresses on our couples shortlist and leave out open coil springs, which carry movement across the bed.
- Budget: we only suggest mattresses in your price range. If fewer than three fit, we say so and show the nearest ones outside it.
Find my mattress gives you that firmness and three mattresses within one step of it, never two from the same brand, ranked by how well they fit your answers and then by our rating. On a product page, SnoozeScore rates the mattress you're viewing as a good fit, borderline or a poor fit, and shows you closer matches where there are any.
A good fit matches the firmness we'd start you on and every shortlist your answers point to. Two or more steps away on firmness is a poor fit, and so is an open coil mattress for a shared bed. Anything in between is borderline.
How we're paid
WantMattress is funded by commission from retailers. When you follow one of our links to a retailer and buy something, the retailer pays us a percentage of the sale. The price you pay does not change.
Most product links on this site go to retailers that pay us commission. Which products appear on a page, and the scores they get, is decided by our research and our review of them.
Commission rates play no part in which products we feature, the scores they receive, or the order they appear in. Our affiliate disclaimer explains how the commission works and where pages are labelled.
How we correct mistakes
Anyone can report a mistake through the contact page. We check the point against our sources. When any page, whether a guide, an article, a product review, a brand page or a discount-code page, gave wrong or unsupported information, we correct it and add a dated correction to that page saying what was wrong and what changed. Guides and articles list it under “Recent updates”; other pages have a “Corrections” section.
The date of the latest correction also appears near the top of the page, next to the updated date, and every correction is collected in our corrections log. Smaller edits, such as changes to wording or links, are not listed one by one.
Who tested it
Every tested product names who tested it, so you can see their weight and how they sleep. Our editorial policy covers the rest: who writes for us, where our facts come from, and how we correct mistakes.
Questions about our review process?
Email [email protected] or send a message through the contact page.