The Highgrove range: open coil, pocket springs and pillow tops
The Solar range is the budget open-coil trio: Solar Backcare is firm, Solar Comfort medium and Solar Supreme medium-firm. Cirrus Luxury is another firm open-coil option, with a hand-tufted finish. Edmonton combines open-coil springs with foam and arrives boxed. These are the linked-spring beds, rather than the ones I'd start with for nightly use.
Aspen Memory Pocket 1500 and Aloe Vera Memory Pocket 1000 combine individual pocket springs with memory foam. The Aspen has a substantial foam layer for a deeper hug. Pillow Cloud Pocket 3000 Pillowtop takes a different route, combining pocket springs and natural fillings with mini-pocket springs in a sewn-on pillow top. The Bourne and Bauer are ottoman bed frames, not mattress models.
What's the bed for?
- The spare room, or the cheapest bed that will do
- Our own bed, every night, memory foam or not
- A soft top sewn on
- Somewhere to put the spare duvet
My nightly-use picks are the Aspen or Aloe Vera, with the Aspen the clearer choice for a side sleeper who wants a substantial foam hug. Start there, then judge the actual selling price against other pocket-sprung beds.
Open coil is for the spare room
A linked spring unit is Highgrove's budget compromise, and sharing one makes that compromise more noticeable. Hourglass springs joined by helical wire pass movement from one sleeper to the other and settle into a dip where the heavier person lies. Keep these for occasional guests or a restricted budget. For two adults on a double, buy pocket springs. For a child's everyday bed, I reject open coil entirely.
Archers lists the Solar Backcare, Solar Comfort, Solar Supreme and Cirrus Luxury with these linked springs, a rod-edge border and double-sided construction. Backcare and Cirrus are firm, Comfort is medium, and Solar Supreme is medium-firm. Being turnable is a plus. It still doesn't get a Solar out of the spare-room heap, however nicely you straighten the cover.
The unhappy Solar Backcare owners agree that it feels softer than advertised. One also reports less depth than listed. Another says the stitching came apart within a fortnight. Supreme owners include someone who found hard edges around a noticeably softer centre, and someone whose edge sagged within days under a teenager. Several owners call the Supreme comfortable and well made.
The Backcare uses a 12.5-gauge open-coil unit. That construction remains my reason to keep it for budget or occasional use, never a child's main bed. Cirrus repeat buyers describe firmness without excessive hardness, and a side-sleeping owner also likes its feel.
Cirrus buyers include people returning for another, who like its firm feel. The Edmonton boxed mattress has reflex foam over open coil, a medium feel and handles for turning. It arrives rolled, and owners like its comfort for the money, though one says the edge drops when sat on. I'd put it alongside the guest-bed mattresses. Even if you're tempted to carry it across to the nightly-use pile.
A Highgrove Solar Comfort may not fit your small double frame: one owner found theirs an inch too big. Match the listed mattress dimensions to your frame's internal space before ordering. Measure the delivered mattress before dressing the bed, and contact the retailer promptly if its dimensions differ from what you ordered.
Pocket springs give you better options for every night
The Aspen and Aloe Vera separate the springs into individual fabric pockets, so each spring can compress more independently than a linked unit. Both add memory foam and both are one-sided. We've finally reached the buy heap, with room left to be fussy. These are the Highgroves I would shortlist for an adult's main bed.
The Aspen Memory Pocket 1500 suits a side sleeper who wants to sink into a substantial foam hug: Archers lists 70mm of memory foam, a teddy-fleece top panel and a foam-encapsulated edge. Its border has vents. If you sleep hot, move towards springs with breathable fibre fillings instead; a deep memory-foam layer holds warmth around you.
The Aloe Vera Memory Pocket 1000 also combines memory foam with pocket springs. You don't get a high spring count in the king size, but individual pockets still give it the edge over the linked Solar units. Choose between these and other memory-foam mattresses by the cushioning you want and the price you actually pay.
Owners of both include second-time buyers. An Aloe Vera owner describes a strong initial smell they attributed to the fire-retardant treatment. Another found their replacement felt different from the previous mattress. The aloe-treated fabric gets no extra weight from me.
The Solar Backcare, Solar Comfort, Solar Supreme, Cirrus Luxury and Edmonton are double-sided mattresses you can turn. The Aspen and Aloe Vera are one-sided, so rotate them head to foot without flipping them onto their underside.
Pillow top: the Pillow Cloud goes in the skip pile
I would skip the Pillow Cloud Pocket 3000 Pillowtop, despite its appealing fillings. Archers lists wool and cotton alongside silk and cashmere, with mini tablet springs sewn into the pillow top. Natural fillings and a sewn-on pillow top, and the pillow top decides it.
Its owners are happy with it, and one finds it too soft. If you avoid pillow tops, leave it here. The skip pile can contain a mattress someone else happily sleeps on. Spend your comparison time on the Aspen and Aloe Vera instead.
Frames are Furniture Village's half of Highgrove
The Bourne and Bauer offer tall winged headboards, slatted bases and substantial storage, so their appeal is strongest when your bedroom lacks cupboard space. Furniture Village describes both as handmade by Highgrove, with a wide fabric choice. The Bourne ottoman is worth comparing with other ottoman frames on support and opening action before you choose the upholstery.
The Bauer's headboard is also buttoned, which is the only difference Furniture Village lists. Choose the appearance you prefer after trying the opening action with a mattress fitted, and confirm the support details for the size you're ordering.
Owners like the appearance and storage, and generally describe the frames as well made. One found the lifting mechanism less robust than expected. Another tightened every nut and bolt after assembly. Try the lift with the intended mattress fitted and see whether it stays raised securely. An empty display base is much easier to lift, however enthusiastic you feel beside it. Ask about slat spacing and centre support too, because those affect the mattress you put on top.