Not everybody wants a plank, and the Bamboo Memory is the bed Romantica made for the people who don't: a gentle bed for not much money. The West Yorkshire bed maker sells three mattresses through Mattress Online, and the other two, the firm Serenade Ortho and the Adagio Extra Firm, come in damask covers. This is the soft-hearted one of the family, a light, cheap, turnable sprung mattress in a knitted bamboo cover with memory foam on one face, and for a guest room or a budget that stops right here, it has a lot going for it.
You'd expect a decent layer of memory foam in a bed called Bamboo Memory. What you get is a centimetre and a half (about half an inch), on one face only, laid over open coil springs of the old wired-together kind. A soft skin on one side, then, and I mean that more kindly than it sounds.
Lie on the foam face and your shoulder settles a little way in, slowly, the way memory foam does, then meets the springs almost at once. Those springs are wired together into one unit, so the surface has a bounce to it and the whole bed moves when you do. Flip it over and the foam has gone. You're on padded springs, firmer and springier again.
That suits a lighter side sleeper, a guest who's staying the weekend, and anyone who can't stretch the budget any further. Couples who share it every night should skip it, and so should heavier people, anyone who wakes when the other side of the bed moves or creaks, and anyone hoping to sink into memory foam. It isn't a child's everyday bed either.
Keep it for the spare room or the tight budget it was made for. If this is going on the bed you sleep in every night, go to the same shop's SleepSoul Balance 800 Pocket Memory, which puts its foam over pocket springs.
The memory foam is a centimetre and a half thick, on one side
I don't talk foam densities. I care how thick the comfort layer is, and 1.5cm is thin for anything with memory in its name. It takes the edge off the springs at your hip and shoulder for the first few minutes you're lying there. It won't cradle you, and it won't soak up a partner turning over the way a proper layer of memory foam does. One owner wrote it off in nine words: "it may as well just be a sprung one".
Thin foam has one upside. Memory foam runs warm whatever a cover promises, and there's so little of it here that the owners who mention heat mostly say it doesn't make them hot, though one who bought it hoping bamboo would keep them cool still found it warm at night. One owner wants the foam twice as thick, and a couple of others talk about buying a topper. If you want cushioning you can feel, buy a bed with more foam in it rather than adding a topper to this one.
Owners find it firmer than its Soft to Medium label
The label says Soft to Medium. The biggest complaint from unhappy owners is that it's firm, and a few go further and call it hard. "This mattress is not soft-medium, it is firm," as one put it. When owners and the label don't match, I go with the owners, so think of the foam face as a medium and the plain sprung face as firmer than that.
The happy owners tell you who it's for: a couple with lighter frames who struggled to find anything softer, a light-built sleeper who finds it supportive, one who calls it ideal for a teen or a smaller, lighter adult, side sleepers, people furnishing a guest room. I go by weight first, then position, and lighter bodies want softer beds, so it makes sense that they get on with it. A heavier body presses through the foam straight away and spends the night on the springs.
The springs are wired together, so movement and squeaks carry across the bed
Open coil is the traditional spring unit: one lattice of springs joined by wire, so pressing on one spot moves the springs around it. Pocket springs every time, for me. Open coil belongs in a spare room or on a tight budget, never under a child every night, because it carries movement across the bed and dips in the middle as it ages.
Owners bear that out. The bounce and a bit of roll-together come up even in the happy reviews, and the unhappy ones talk about springs they can feel and springs that squeak as they turn. One owner who sits on the edge to get in and out says the noise carries to the room below. Earplugs never changed anything for me, so I'd steer a light sleeper to a quieter bed rather than tell them to block it out.
The same bounce has its fans. If you change position a lot in the night, a springy surface is easier to roll over on than deep foam that hangs on to you. And for a guest sleeping alone, none of the motion talk applies.
Bamboo is mostly a fabric story
The bamboo is in the knitted cover and nowhere else. That cover is sold as naturally hypoallergenic, a fabric that fights allergens and makes a dust mite free space. A cover is one layer of a whole mattress, and dust mites live in pillows, duvets and the fillings under the cover too, so a fabric can't make a bed free of them. Where a mattress carries a recognised allergy seal, Allergy UK's or another named scheme, I'll name it. This one carries none, so read hypoallergenic as a word on a label.
If allergies are why you're shopping, a protector you can wash hot will do more than any fibre in a cover, and so will airing the bed. Romantica's care guide asks for a protector anyway. Take symptoms that keep you awake to your GP, not to a mattress label. Owners can't agree on the cover itself, either: some single out the bamboo cover as a plus, one calling it a "lovely extra external coating", while others call it synthetic or a bit scratchy.
It turns over, and it's light enough to do it often
Turnable is better, to my mind. Flip a mattress and the wear is shared between two faces, so it goes on for longer, and one-sided beds were always more of a saving for the factory than a feature for you. This one has two sleeping faces and handles sewn into its sides for turning, and I like seeing them on a bed this cheap. A single weighs 17kg and a king 28.5kg, and owners say it's light enough to turn on your own. It's 24cm (about 9.4 inches) deep and arrives flat, not rolled. Air it for at least four hours before the sheets go on, as Romantica asks.
Romantica's care guide for its sprung mattresses says to turn it over and swing it head to foot once a fortnight for the first twelve weeks, then once a month, or hollows form where you sleep. Follow it, because a guarantee claim depends on the care instructions having been followed. On this bed the schedule has a catch. Every flip puts the other face on top, so half your nights are on the firmer sprung side. If you can only get on with one face, you're stuck choosing between comfort and the care guide, which is one more reason this belongs in a guest room.
The guarantee runs one year. Romantica talks about seven to ten years of comfort from its mattresses if you look after them, and only the first of those years is guaranteed, so plan around the shorter number.
What to buy instead
Buy the SleepSoul Balance 800 Pocket Memory if the mattress is for your own bed. Mattress Online sells it as well. Under its memory foam are 800 pocket springs, every one in a cloth pocket of its own and free of the wire that ties an open coil together, so when your partner rolls over in the night, the springs under you barely move. It carries a ten-year guarantee where the Romantica has one. It's graded Medium, a step up from this one's label, and given how firm owners find the Romantica, the two will feel closer than their labels suggest.
You give up turning. The Balance is a one-sided mattress that arrives rolled, and it's 22cm deep. For a bed you sleep on every night, I'd make that trade without a second thought, and keep the Romantica for the room your guests use twice a year.