Plenty of people never took to foam. They want springs under them, a flat buttoned top that stays where it's put and a mattress they can turn over when the clocks change, and Bensons for Beds still makes one for them in the Maybury Ortho Comfort. Lie down and there's a little give at the surface before the springs push straight back, while the tufts keep the top level from your shoulders to your heels. It's a plain, old-fashioned bed, and I like it for that.
This is Bensons' own mattress: 1000 pocket springs under a hypoallergenic comfort layer, hand tufted through a Belgian damask cover on both faces, 26.5cm (about 10.5 inches) deep. It's the medium of a pair, and once you lie down, the grade is what tells it apart from its firm twin, the Maybury Ortho. Side sleepers take this one; back and front sleepers take the Ortho.
Anyone who knows it as the Exminster Ortho Comfort has met this bed before, because Bensons relaunched it under the new name. Its published build also matches the Highbury Ortho Comfort, a bed I know well, and I rated that one a solid budget medium: traditional, supportive, fine on my side and firmer than its label. Expect the same here.
Nothing about the build changed with the name. The price is a different story, because Bensons moves it a lot on this family. On offer it's a fair bed. At the full ticket I'd walk past it. Avoid it too if you're slim and sleep on your side, or if what you want from a mattress is to sink into it.
The Medium Maybury suits an average-weight side sleeper
Choose by your weight before your position. At an average weight on your side, this is the Maybury you want: a medium lets your shoulder and hip press in far enough for your spine to stay level, where the firm Ortho pushes back harder at both. On your back the Medium keeps your hips up well enough, but if you sleep that way most nights, or face down, the firm twin gives you the flatter support you're after.
Read it as a medium that leans firm. Every brand's medium is its own, and on this one the tufting pulls the cover and fillings down onto the springs and pins them there, so there's no puffy pad to sink into. Under about nine stone on your side, that lean is too much: your shoulder won't get far enough in, and you'll wake with it sore. Look at the Eve Hybrid Duo at the same shop instead. Over about eighteen stone, go to the firm grade whatever position you sleep in.
Share the bed and the pocketing helps. Every spring is wrapped on its own, so a partner's restless night stays mostly on their half, where an old open coil would pass each turn straight across to you. Two adults on a double is the mistake I see most often, so if the room takes it, order the king. Bensons sells it from single up to super king, and to me a king is the proper double for two.
Hand tufting keeps this Medium on the firm side
Here, the Ortho in the name means firmer fillings hand tufted through the mattress to hold the comfort layer in place and give it a more supportive feel. That's where the firm lean comes from. Hand tufting is skilled work and it does a job here, because the filling can't drift into lumps and the top stays level. The buttons are the price of that, and you'll either love them or want a thick protector over them. A machine-tufted bed with the same springs and fillings would sleep the same to me, so I credit the craft for what it does and judge the bed on what's inside.
What's inside is modest. There's one comfort layer, made mostly from recycled material and sold as hypoallergenic, under a damask cover that lets air through. It softens the first touch of the springs and leaves you very little to settle into, which suits anyone who likes to lie on a bed and hates climbing out of a hollow to turn over. If dust gets to you, a protector that goes in a hot wash is the practical fix.
It's made in a UK factory holding the Furniture Makers' Manufacturing Guild Mark and a BSI Kitemark. Both are awarded to the factory for the way it builds, and I'm pleased to see them on a bed like this. They tell you about the workshop, and the springs and fillings tell you about the mattress. Under its old name it came from a Kitemark-accredited factory too, and the relaunch adds the Manufacturing Guild Mark beside it. The springs, fillings and cover are as they were, so anyone who slept well on the old version can buy this one knowing exactly what's coming.
1000 pocket springs, a light count that still does the job
A thousand is on the light side for me, but these are pocket springs, which is what I want under anyone, so the count doesn't put me off. The edge has extra support built in to cut down on roll-off, and that counts for a lot on a double, where a soft edge leaves two of you on what sleeps like a small double.
Sit on the side for a minute before you buy. Bensons is a good place to try beds, and the Highbury Ortho Comfort's published build matches this one, so lie down on whichever is out on the shop floor, on your side, and you'll know before you order whether that firm lean suits your shoulder.
Double-sided, and too deep for a shallow sheet
Being double-sided is what I like most about it. A bed you can turn over spreads the wear across two faces, and at the same price I'd always take one over a no-turn bed. At 26.5cm it's more than a shallow fitted sheet will stretch over comfortably, so check the pocket on yours before it arrives, because a sheet that only just reaches turns every flip into a wrestle. When the new one comes, pay Bensons to take the old mattress for recycling. Far too many end up in landfill, and the collection is a small price next to the bed you've just bought.
If you'd like the 40 Night Comfort Guarantee as a safety net, put a mattress protector on from the first night, since you need one to qualify. It swaps the mattress for another one, with charges, so choose between the Medium and the Firm carefully before you order.
A fair buy on offer, and only on offer
The Maybury Ortho Comfort is a sound traditional bed, and its full price asks too much for one. Watch the price and buy when a proper offer comes, whichever sale it turns up in. Black Friday happens to be my favourite of them, the 'was' price game and all, but any genuine offer on this bed is your moment. With the offer in front of you, put the Maybury side by side with the Eve Hybrid Duo before you pay. For a side sleeper who wants springs and buttons, I'd buy this one on offer and not a day before.
What to buy instead
If what you want is springs, buttons and a bed you can turn, buy the Maybury when it's on offer. If turning doesn't matter to you, the Eve Hybrid Duo is where I'd put my own money at Bensons. To my mind it's the far better bed: memory foam over two layers of pocket springs, built well above its price, and soft enough to let a side sleeper's shoulder and hip sink in while the waist stays supported. You give up the turning, because it's one-sided, and the memory foam gets warm after a while, so a hot sleeper should weigh that against the Maybury's springier, more open build.
Back and front sleepers should take the Maybury Ortho, the firm half of the pair. And if your heart is set on this build, keep the Highbury Ortho Comfort in view as well. Its published build matches the Maybury's, so check both prices the week you're ready and take home the lower one.