For a back sleeper who likes a bed the old-fashioned way, firm enough to keep you up on top of it and with two faces so you can turn it, the Maybury Ortho is the one to look at. It's the firm half of a pair in Bensons for Beds' own range, with pocket springs under firmer fillings tufted by hand and a damask cover over both faces. Bensons used to sell it as the Exminster Ortho, and I tried it in one of its stores in May 2024, under that old name.
The grade is the one thing that separates it from its twin, the Maybury Ortho Comfort, which is the same build in Medium. On my side the firmness was nearly too much for me, and my hip and shoulder hardly sank in at all. The springs were the nice surprise. They answered every move I made, and rolling from one side to the other took no effort. Back and front sleepers of average weight or more are the people it suits, and side sleepers belong on the Comfort.
It's a fair bed, and I'd buy it on offer, never at full price.
The Maybury Ortho is properly firm, so choose it by your weight
Weight comes first for me, then position. Lie on your back on this one at an average weight or more and your hips and shoulders stay at one height, with steady support right under your middle and nothing giving way. Lie face down and you get the same flat, level feel, with your hips kept up level with your shoulders. That's the group it's made for, and if you've slept on a firm bed for years and liked it, you'll feel at home straight away.
Under about nine stone, or on your side at most weights, the Firm grade gives your shoulder almost nothing to sink into, and the Comfort is kinder. More recently I lay on the Highbury Ortho, which Bensons builds to the same published spec. On my back and my front it suited me well, and on my side it was short on give again, which is the pattern you'd expect from a firm tufted bed under a lighter side sleeper. In a Bensons store, lie on the Maybury on your back and then roll onto your side, and you'll know inside a minute which of the pair is yours.
Ortho on the Maybury means firmer fillings, tufted through by hand
Ortho here is Bensons' word for the firmer fillings and the tufting that runs through them, and that's what you're paying for. The tufts are the buttons you can see across each face. They tie the fillings down through the depth of the mattress so the layers stay where they were put, and they give the surface its firm, slightly old-school feel. I like seeing the craft. I still judge a bed on what's under the buttons, and here that's fibre and springs.
Between you and the springs sits a fibre comfort layer, three-quarters of it recycled, which Bensons labels hypoallergenic. Over that goes a Belgian damask, a woven, patterned cover that feels crisp under a sheet. With fibre on top of springs there's no slow memory foam sink to climb out of when you roll over, and that suits a back sleeper who likes to move freely.
One spring count for every size of Maybury Ortho
Bensons gives a single figure, 1,000 pocket springs, for every size from single to super king. Ask which size that count belongs to before you order. If it's the double's, that's on the light side to me. Bought on offer, that's a count I'm happy with, and it's still a good bed, because they're pocket springs, and pocket springs are always my first choice.
Every spring here sits in a pocket of its own and gives independently of its neighbours. My partner gets teased in our house about turning over, and that's why I'd always put a couple on pocket springs. When one of you shifts about, the springs under the other one barely move, where the wired-together springs of an open coil carry it across the bed.
Two sleeping faces, so the Maybury Ortho turns
Turnable is better. A mattress with two faces spreads the wear across both of them, so I'd pick it over a one-sided bed every time, and this one gets that right. Turning a sprung double is a lot easier with a second pair of hands, so plan it for when someone's home to help.
At 26.5cm deep (about ten and a half inches) it takes ordinary fitted sheets with no fuss. It comes flat, not rolled up in a box. Measure the turn on your stairs and the width of the bedroom door before delivery day.
Wait for an offer on the Maybury Ortho
Mattresses are on sale for most of the year, and almost nobody needs to pay the full price for one. This is a plain, honest build of tufted fibre over pocket springs, and I rate it for that. There's nothing in it you need to pay the full ticket for. Keep an eye on the price and buy when it drops.
If you get the grade wrong anyway, Bensons' 40 Night Comfort Guarantee is your way out, and it's an exchange for another mattress. Choose the grade with care the first time. For my own side of the bed I'd take the Comfort. For a back sleeper who loves firm, this one gets my vote, provided you catch it on offer.
What to buy instead
Side sleepers should buy the Maybury Ortho Comfort. It keeps the springs, the hand tufting and the two faces, and its Medium grade lets your shoulder and hip sink in far enough to keep your spine straight. A light side sleeper, under about nine stone, wants more give than even that, and the Eve Hybrid Duo in the same shop is softer at the shoulder.
If firm is right for you and the Maybury isn't on offer, look at the Highbury Ortho. Bensons builds it to the same published spec. Whichever of the two has the better offer on the day is the one to buy.
The Bensons Ortho Pocket 1000 is one more firm, tufted pocket-sprung bed on the same shop floor, and it gives a back sleeper steady, level support of its own. The difference is the turn: it has one sleeping face and stands 23cm deep, so you rotate it and never flip it. Put the two side by side and I'd take the Maybury, because a bed you can turn shares its wear between both faces.