What our reviewers found
Listen to the review on our podcast
Sometimes you don't want a showpiece mattress. All you want is something simple, supportive and affordable to get the job done. The Highbury Ortho Comfort Mattress from Bensons is just that. It's an entry-level orthopaedic model based around an unpretentious 1000 pocket spring system with a polyester fibre comfort layer. There are no luxuries here, it's basic, and for what it is it does a reasonable job of providing a decent night's sleep, if your expectations are suitably low.
First impressions
The Highbury Ortho Comfort has a clean, traditional look with its hand-tufted surface and patterned damask cover. It's 26.5 cm deep, so it has enough bulk to look respectable in the bed, without being as heavy and awkward to handle as the premium options. The edges are firmer under the fingers, and the top surface has a neat, evenly spaced tufting pattern. It feels like a budget design, but at least it's been well presented. There's no smell or off-gassing and the finish feels tidy enough. For a mattress built to a price point, it looks decent out of the wrapper.
Construction
Inside, it's all about simplicity. There are 1000 individually housed pocket springs forming the support core, each of which moves independently of its neighbour, allowing the mattress to adapt to pressure as it's applied. The advantage is better contouring, and less movement transfer than a basic open coil model. The perimeter edges are reinforced to stop roll-off and the whole thing is finished with a hand-tufted damask cover to hold the layers together. The filling above the spring unit is polyester fibres. It's soft, light and completely synthetic. The fibres offer a small amount of surface cushioning, but they lack the resilience and breathability of natural materials. If you've slept on a higher-end mattress before, you'll feel the difference straight away.
Comfort
The comfort level is set at medium and it's about right. It's a touch soft on the surface, followed by a steady predictable spring support underneath. I didn't feel discomfort when lying on my back provided I stayed for short intervals but the support felt decent despite its lack of plushness. On my side, the polyester layer compresses quickly so you feel closer to the springs than you'd probably like. It's not uncomfortable, just basic. Sleeping on the front was ok too. The firmer support prevents sagging at the hips, but there isn't much contouring or pressure relief.
If you're upgrading from a tired or sagging mattress, you'll find the Highbury Ortho Comfort an improvement. But after a few nights you start to notice the limitations. The polyester top layer just doesn't have much depth or rebound. Overall, the comfort feels quite flat. The springs are doing a good job of keeping the structure intact, but the surface is lacking in the refinement or plushness that even a mid-range mattress achieves. Serviceable, not satisfying.
Temperature and breathability
Airflow is one of the better aspects of this mattress. The damask cover and open fibre top layer allow air to move freely through the mattress, so it remains fairly neutral in temperature. It doesn't trap heat the way foam does, and the surface feels dry in the morning. The polyester isn't as breathable as cotton or wool though, so it will feel slightly warmer in summer months. In winter the insulation is fine. It's good enough for the price, but you won't mistake it for a naturally breathable mattress.
Motion transfer
Because the 1000 pocket springs are working independently, motion is reasonably well controlled. You'll still feel some movement if your partner shifts around, but much less than you would on a traditional open coil design. For single sleepers it's fine. For couples it's adequate but not exceptional. There's a little bounce on the surface but it settles quickly.
Edge support
Thanks to the reinforced border, the edges hold up well. You can sit on the edge without sliding off, and the sides hold their shape well for a mattress at this price point. It doesn't feel hollow or flimsy, which is a big plus. The edge stitching is tight and even, which should help it hold its structure for longer than you might expect.
Everyday use
It's good to see it's double sided at this price. Flipping it over every few months will help extend its lifespan and prevent impressions from forming. It's light enough to turn with relative ease, and the tufts hold firm after rotation. The damask fabric is durable and easy to care for, though it will show scuffs and marks faster than more expensive woven fabrics. After a few weeks of testing, the comfort layer has already softened slightly but not dramatically. It's a mattress you'll want to look after and maintain regularly to get the best value out of it.
Who this mattress suits
The Highbury Ortho Comfort suits budget-conscious shoppers who need a simple, firmish mattress for occasional or short-term use. It's ideal as a spare room, rental property or first mattress for someone moving into a new home. Back and front sleepers will find the support level acceptable, and lighter users may be surprised by how comfortable it is. An honest, no-frills product that prioritises practicality over indulgence.
Who it doesn't suit
If you want a premium feel or naturally breathable materials, this isn't the one for you. Side sleepers may find it too firm at the shoulder, and the thin polyester comfort layer lets the springs show through. Heavier sleepers will likely feel the springs through the polyester after a while. It also doesn't justify its current retail price, which feels a bit steep for the spec. Better value models are out there if you can stretch your budget slightly. It's not a bad mattress, just a basic one that's priced as if it was mid-range.
Care and maintenance
Rotate and flip the mattress every month for the first few months, then quarterly after that. Because it's double sided it should give good lifespan if treated properly. Use a breathable protector to prevent sweat and dust build-up, and leave it to air for 20 minutes each morning before making the bed. The tufts and damask cover will help hold the structure in place if you look after it, and that will help keep it feeling comfortable for longer.
Verdict
The Highbury Ortho Comfort Mattress is a simple, entry-level pocket sprung mattress that performs about as you'd expect. It's firm enough for good alignment and breathable enough to stay comfortable, but its polyester comfort layer holds it back. Functional, not refined. For a spare bed, student room or starter home, it will do the job. For a main mattress it's worth saving up a little longer for something with better materials. It's not a bad mattress, just a basic one that's a touch overpriced for what it is.
If you want something simple, supportive, and easy to maintain, the Highbury Ortho Comfort is perfectly serviceable. Just go in with the right expectations, it's a budget mattress in every sense of the word.
Why you can trust WantMattress We spend hours testing (and/or researching) every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about
how we test .
Published: 12 February 2024 · Updated: 24 March 2024
Written by
Ron Burns , Staff Writer, Beds and Bed Frames
Tested in store by
Becky Reeve , Staff Writer, Mattress Expert · February 2024
