Your list is short: a mattress that's properly hard, a name you recognise on the label, and no fortune spent getting both. I understand the appeal, and the Miracoil Serenity Ortho at Furniture Village is pitched squarely at you. It's the open-coil half of Silentnight's Serenity pair: the maker's own Miracoil springs under a thin quilt of fibre, hand tufted, made in the UK, 25cm deep and sold in a single grade, Extra firm. Its sibling, the Mirapocket Serenity 1400 Ortho, is the same hard bed built on pocket springs. Lie on your back on this one and you stay right on top of it, with only a skin of fibre between you and the springs.
The person it's built for is someone heavy who sleeps on their back or front and likes a bed that barely gives. Even then, I'd talk you out of it. Extra firm is a specialist grade, and an open coil is no way to get it. Avoid it as a side sleeper, or if you're slightly built, because your shoulder never sinks in far enough to take the pressure off. Get a bed this hard on pocket springs, and in this shop my pick is the Revitalise Ortho 1400.
Miracoil is Silentnight's own spring unit, joined up and zoned
I'll give the springs their credit first. Miracoil is Silentnight's continuous coil, its own take on open coil, with the springs running in rows and joined into one unit, and on the Serenity they're zoned along the length of the bed, which is more thought than an open coil usually gets. Zones only help if they sit where your hips and shoulders fall, and on a very tall or very short body they can miss. I'm cool on Silentnight's ranges as a rule, and that's my taste talking. My problem with this bed is the springs, not the name on it.
Furniture Village sells it on having twice as many springs as a regular open coil. Ask in store for the actual count in your size before you order, so you're comparing a number with a number when you stand it against the pocket-sprung beds.
Miracoil or pocket springs? On an Extra firm bed, pocket springs
Pocket springs every time for me, and the case for them gets stronger the firmer the bed. Each pocket spring sits in its own fabric sleeve and answers only the weight pressing on it, so a heavy hip pushes down its own springs while your shoulder rests on different ones. A joined unit moves more as one piece: press down in one spot and the springs around it get pulled along. On a soft or medium mattress the comfort layers cover a lot of that. On an Extra firm bed, support is the whole reason you're buying, and that's exactly where I want every spring doing its own job.
Then there's the night itself. I'm a light sleeper and I wake easily, which is why I care so much about movement across a bed. On joined springs, when the person next to you turns over, the movement travels through the unit to your side. Pocket springs keep far more of it where it started. Buy them if you share with someone restless, because that alone would settle it for me.
On the Serenity, Ortho means the Extra firm grade and a tufted top
Ortho on this bed means the Extra firm grade plus a thin fibre top tufted through to the springs, which keeps very little between your body and them. Whether that suits your back comes down to your weight far more than the name. Firm-is-good-for-your-back is the belief I'd most like to talk people out of, and I'd start almost everyone on medium-firm instead. Weight comes before position in my book: the more you weigh, the firmer you can go, and a side sleeper wants a grade softer than a back sleeper of the same build. Under about nine stone, you'll find Extra firm too hard whichever way you lie.
How I weighed it up
I judged the Serenity Ortho on its build, from the Miracoil unit up through the tufted fibre top, and on its single Extra firm grade. Then I set it against the pocket-sprung Extra firm beds in the same shop, starting with the Revitalise Ortho 1400, a bed I know first-hand from a Furniture Village store. A hard bed on joined springs has one job to do for one kind of sleeper, and the question I asked was whether it does that job better than the pocket-sprung beds sold beside it. It doesn't.
The fibre on top comes from plastic bottles, and it's pinned in place
The quilt is Eco Comfort fibre made from plastic bottles, hand tufted so the stitching runs right through the mattress and holds the filling where it was put. I'll credit the craft there: tufts stop a fibre layer drifting into lumps and hollows. The mattress is also treated with Purotex, which is meant to keep dust mites away, and that's what hypoallergenic means on this bed. If dust sets you sneezing, put a protector over it that you can wash hot, because that does more for you than any treatment on the mattress.
Living with a one-sided bed
Rotate it head to foot regularly, and more often in the first few months, because there's no turning this one over to share the wear. Furniture Village counts dips in the fillings from body weight as normal settling, not a fault, and says rotating keeps them down, so keep at it. I'd pick a mattress you can flip, since two faces share the wear, but none of the Extra firm beds I'd send you to turns over either, so here the springs decide it.
It's listed in single, double, king and super king, with no small double, and the depth takes an ordinary fitted sheet. Check your slats sit no more than 6cm apart, which is Silentnight's own advice, and put a centre rail with feet under anything double or wider.
What to buy instead
The Silentnight Revitalise Ortho 1400 is dearer, and the extra goes exactly where this bed falls short: pocket springs, 1,400 of them counted in a king, under the same Extra firm grade at much the same depth. It does the job a very firm mattress is for: on my back it held me flat and level, hips and shoulders at one height, and it was every bit as hard as its label says, too hard for me as a side sleeper. If you're a heavier back sleeper who wants a hard bed and knows it, that's the result you're after, and it's worth the difference.
Rather stay in the Serenity range? Its pocket-sprung sibling, the Mirapocket Serenity 1400 Ortho, is dearer too, and pairs this same Extra firm grade with Mirapocket. That's Silentnight's own take on pocket springs, built its own way, with each spring free to answer the weight on it, which makes it a far better partner for a grade this hard. If you're not sure you want a bed this firm at all, the Revitalise Refresh 800 is a grade softer, Firm on 800 pocket springs counted in a king, and a better bet for most people than any Extra firm bed.