Skip to content

Independent UK mattress reviews since 2018

Find my mattress
  1. Home
  2. Comparison
  3. Flaxby vs Emma Mattress Reviews

Flaxby vs Emma Mattress Reviews

Compare Flaxby and Emma mattresses side by side: owner satisfaction, support, durability and price, based on aggregated customer reviews.

Checked byBecky Reeve, Staff Writer, Mattress Expert
SourceCompiled from WantMattress review data

Want Mattress is supported by the shoppers who use it. Some links on Want Mattress are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Want Mattress may make a small amount of money. Read our disclaimer.

Brand

Flaxby

RatingNot yet scored
Price range£1,499 – £3,899
Brand

Emma

4.5/5Owners1,097 reviews
Price range£193 – £849

Only Emma has enough owner reviews to score, so there is no head-to-head verdict here.

Becky’s take

By Becky Reeve

Checked against current models and prices in October 2026

Flaxby is worth it over Emma, even though it costs more. Flaxby is made in Yorkshire, sold at Dreams, and it's pocket springs under natural fillings with no foam. Emma is the German boxed brand on every ad break, and the mattress has never struck me as the reason it's famous. Its range is memory foam over pocket springs, mostly medium, with the Original Lite 2025 at soft-medium and the Diamond Spring Free Deluxe at firm.

Memory foam lets your shoulder and hip settle in, which I enjoy as a side sleeper, but it holds your heat. Flaxby's springs and fibre push back and let air through, so you float rather than sink. If you want that slow sink, buy the Emma, though for all Emma's advertising, Flaxby has more owner reviews, which surprised me.

Emma's one strong argument is its 200-night trial, while a Flaxby gets judged on a Dreams shop floor. If you want medium-firm, neither brand makes one, so I'd send you to a boxed Origin hybrid instead.

Head to head

Flaxby has sprung throughout, with pocket springs or a hybrid build in every model; Emma has 14 of its 15 mattresses sprung and 1 all memory foam. Emma is the budget choice of the two: Flaxby's cheapest mattress costs several times as much. At the top end Flaxby goes further still. Flaxby doesn't have enough owner reviews with us yet to score fairly.

How they differ

FlaxbyEmma
Mattresses we list1015
Price range£1,499 – £3,899£193 – £849
Owner ratingNot enough reviews yet
4.5/5Owners1,097 reviews

Mattresses only. Owner ratings are the review-weighted average across each brand’s mattresses on UK retailer sites. Prices read 11 November 2026.

Flaxby

Flaxby is a natural mattress range handmade by Harrison Spinks in Yorkshire and sold through Dreams. Since October 2026 the mattresses are the Flaxby Natural range: wool, flax and hemp with pocket springs, with cotton, cashmere, mohair, alpaca, lambswool and silk on the dearer models, built without foam or glue.

The range comes in three kinds: single-sided flat mattresses, double-sided Dual Season models you can turn, and pillow tops with a fixed soft layer. Dreams sells the Dual Season models as having a warmer side and a cooler side, though on the Hempstead its own layer list puts the same wool and cotton blends on both faces.

Emma

Emma is an immensely popular German sleep brand that specialises in bed in a box mattresses. First clamouring to fame in 2015 but achieving real velocity from 2018 onwards, Emma is one of the last standing in the war on sleep having bested Eve, Casper and Leesa, all of whom had similar marketing objectives and business models. To date, Emma offers a short core range of mattresses commercially through their own website with store and retailer derived versions for the masses of retailers looking to piggyback the brand's success. The mattresses all feature foam as a staple with some featuring additional springs. Regardless of which version you choose, comfort is almost guaranteed with thousands of satisfied customers to date.

Recently Emma rebranded to become known as Emma Sleep and pivoted their focus toward other items in the bedding sector ranging from bed frames, pillows, duvets and protectors.

Flaxby owner satisfaction

Owners of the earlier Flaxby range, the Masters Guild and Oxtons Guild mattresses that the Flaxby Natural models replaced, praised comfort and support most: “I have found it extremely comfortable and I get a good sleep”, and “Feels so supportive”. One noted that “the edges are very firmly sprung so if you sit on the bed to put your socks on, you don't slip off”.

Their complaints centred on the old pillow tops, the 4450 in particular, softening or dipping early: “after 6 months it dipped massively and became unbearably uncomfortable”. Others found the delivered mattress firmer than the one in the showroom, and a few noticed a natural-fibre smell, which one owner called “a bit ‘sheepy’”. Those reviews describe a different build, so read them as a guide to how Flaxby's natural fillings settle and smell, and judge the new models on their own construction.

Flaxby supportiveness

Every Flaxby Natural mattress sits on Harrison Spinks pocket springs. Dreams' layer diagrams describe the main spring layers as micro pocket springs, with thicker Cortec springs round the edge to firm up the border, and the three pillow tops add a Posturfil spring layer. The range leans firm. The Flaxmoor 2500 is Very Firm only and the Woolcroft 3500 Firm only, the Hempstead and Cashmere Vale come in Firm or Very Firm, and only the Silkstone, the Woolcroft Loft and the Alpaca Moor go softer than Medium Firm. Pick the grade by your weight first, then your position: heavier back and front sleepers go firmer, lighter and side sleepers softer.

Flaxby durability

Durability comes down to the fillings and whether you can turn the mattress. Natural fibres settle where you sleep, and Harrison Spinks' care guide calls body impressions a normal feature of handmade mattresses, so expect a gentle dip along your side of the bed and rotate it to share the wear. The three Dual Season models turn over as well, which is the build I'd choose for a long life. The pillow tops can't be turned, and a soft top only goes softer. The guarantee covers defects in construction or materials, repaired or replaced at the maker's discretion, and the care guide sets no dip depth that counts as a fault.

Flaxby best offers

We've managed to find the following top deals from across the web on Flaxby mattresses.

Emma owner satisfaction

Emma Sleep’s entire business model is focussed toward consumer satisfaction. Key parts of their marketing strategy comes from word of mouth and statistics show that people buy from people. What makes Emma stand out from the crowd is an interesting shift in consumer buying behaviour. Previously, if you bought a mattress and didn’t enjoy it, you were out of luck, not so with the rise of Emma. Now, if you don’t like your mattress you can arrange a return within Emma’s trial, which the brand advertises as up to 200 nights when you buy direct. This shift has proved extremely positive for customers and has increased satisfaction in the lineup.

To date, Emma has amassed more than 53,000 reviews on Trustpilot (checked 9 October 2026), a fantastic display given the company's fairly new tenure in the industry.

Emma supportiveness

Firmness is a very subjective thing which proves a particularly tough nut to crack when you are producing one mattress to suit all people. So much so that Emma has prototyped and tested numerous models previous to going to market in order to get that mix just right. The result? Emma’s own range runs from a medium tension to a medium firm one. Medium is a great supportive rating as it gives the user enough body contouring and support in the back and neck while giving enough softness and compression to accommodate those who sleep on their side or are of a lower BMI. It really is considered the one-size-fits-all approach and it’s one that suits many who purchase an Emma mattress, just take a look at the thousands of reviews to date.

Emma durability

With the mid-range price point of Emma products, it’s important for shoppers that the bed lasts for a number of years. Generally we find companies consistently trying to cut costs at the expense of durability. Fortunately Emma already has a unique business model as the mattresses follow the rolled and bed-in-a-box model that allows savings through logistics and delivery meaning Emma can spend more on materials while still finding profit. The result of this means you get a mattress that is affordable and of higher quality than competing brands which, as a result of the quality increase, is more durable and lasts longer as a result. It’s a win for everyone.

Emma best offers

We've managed to find the following top deals from across the web on Emma mattresses.

Corrections

When we get something wrong, we fix it and say so here. All corrections

9 October 2026
We called Emma a British manufacturer, said it sold two mattresses and offered a 100-night trial. Emma is a German brand with a wider range, and it advertises a trial of up to 200 nights.

Owner reviews of Emma mattresses

5 Mandy

It's been 2 years now, so here is a review after 2 years of sleeping on it. I am a larger lady who has many disabilities that cause a lot of bodily pain, I have Neuropathy, fibromyalgia, osteoarthritis, ME, spondylitis of the neck and spine and a crumbling spine, sciatica etc. I tell you this because it's very important to find that perfect mattress when you have physical disabilities. I can not tell you the difference this mattress has made to my life. As soon as I lay down on it, it was like heaven, it was like I was weightless and 2 years on it is still the same, every time I get on it, it feels as good as the first time. My pain levels at night decreased by a lot, i used to wake constantly with hip pain, since sleeping on this Emma Mattress I have not woke with hip pain once! my sleep is deeper and longer, which has made a massive difference in my everyday life. The mattress has zero lumps, bumps, springs, coils, it's just like a smooth cloud. The mattress is that fantastic and feels so good under your body that when I put my electric blanket on top of it, and I have a very expensive thick electric blanket, I hated the feel of it and had to take my electric blanket off. You will be just fine with your electric blanket on top of the mattress, but having fibromyalgia, they used to call fibromyalgia 'The princess and the pea disease' because you can feel every stitch, lump, bump ect and every stitch, lump and bump causes so much pain, but the Emma mattress feels like a smooth cloud, you actually feel weightless. It was the best decision I ever made to get this mattress, it was more expensive than any other mattress I have purchased previously, but it is worth so much more than that just to have a pain free, long, cosy nights sleep. It's also not to hot for menopause, I don't know why that myth was put out there but it's just fine temperature wise. I also bought my son one, he has cerebral palsy and he agrees with me about how amazing they are, especially if you suffer from any aches and pains. Just buy one, do it, you will be amazed how great they are.

4 Richard

I think the mattress is great but my wife thinks it is a little hard. I have not had any back ache since we bought the matress. Our previous mattress was killing my back and had become extremly unsupportive. The delivery staff were great as they brought the new mattress in and removed the old one. I would have never been able to move the old mattress so having the gentlemen take our wornout one away was really helpful. We left the Emma mattress to vent and take shape over the stipulated time. Not sure how we could ever have returned it though as the delicery staff removed the box it came in and I would never have been able to compress it into such a small roll again. The extensive strong plastic wrap retained the compression forces which I imagine were processed at the factory so I can not think how it could be completed at home. I love the mattress and have slept well since it was delivered and the back ache has not returned.

4 Siya

We bought the Emma Hybrid AirGrid Mattress in October as a replacement for our king-sized Sloom mattress from South Africa after relocating to the UK, and we've been extremely happy with the experience so far. The mattress strikes a great balance in firmness - it's supportive without being too hard, and we've had no back pain since using it. Sleep quality has been noticeably better, and it's been comfortable from the very first night without needing a long 'breaking in' period. Delivery was smooth and right on schedule, which made the whole purchase experience stress-free. What really stood out for us was the price as it was significantly more affordable than other mattresses in the same range, yet the quality hasn't felt compromised at all. Overall, we're very pleased with our purchase and would confidently recommend the Emma Hybrid AirGrid to anyone looking for a high-quality, comfortable mattress at a great price.

2 Stuart

Having slept on an Emma memory foam mattress a few times and loved it when staying with family I was expecting great things from what I assumed would be an upgraded and better product. As well as the experience on the memory foam mattress I’d spent weeks reading reviews and was confident this mattress would deliver on the three things we most wanted - comfort, minimal motion transfer, and a cool sleep. Sad to say my wife and I are disappointed on two of those things. Comfort wise I’ve no grumbles, but I’m a fidget and mover in bed and my wife reckons it’s like sleeping on a boat, and to be honest, I don’t find it any better than the 30 yr old mattress we both got rid of. In addition we both find it quite a bit warmer than the old mattress as well. With the pocket springs covered by layers of various foams it is nothing like the memory foam mattress we’d tried at our daughters. I’m disappointed that I can easily feel the springs through the sides and bottom (just a couple of layers of fabric) - in fact it actually feels quite cheaply made to me. I guess I should have expected this from a roll up mattress, but no one mentioned this in any of the dozens of reviews I read! Maybe I’m just fussy, but I wouldn’t get another one.

2 Col

I’m a bit disappointed with this product. We previously owned an Emma Original mattress purchased in 2020, which was the best mattress we’ve ever had. Based on that experience, I expected this one to be the same or at least similar. However, despite being called “Original,” it is nothing like the one we had before. The old mattress was entirely memory foam, whereas this one has pocket springs with only a thin layer of foam on top, which makes it feel quite firm. Had I realised this, I would never have purchased it. In addition, because the underside consists of hard springs, the mattress slides on the base and needs to be pushed back into place regularly. MattressOnline have offered to exchange the mattress for a different one but as we would be unable to test the mattress, we would simply be swapping it for another unknown model that may not be any better, so we have decided to keep it. However, this will definitely be the last time we purchase an Emma mattress

This website uses cookies to give you the best experience.We use cookies. Cookie policy