Skip to content

Independent UK mattress reviews since 2018

Find my mattress
  1. Home
  2. Comparison
  3. Harrison Spinks vs Dormeo Mattress Reviews

Harrison Spinks vs Dormeo Mattress Reviews

Compare Harrison Spinks and Dormeo mattresses side by side: owner satisfaction, support, durability and price, based on aggregated customer reviews.

Checked byBecky Reeve, Staff Writer, Mattress Expert
SourceCompiled from WantMattress review data

Want Mattress is supported by the shoppers who use it. Some links on Want Mattress are referral links. If you use one of these and buy something, Want Mattress may make a small amount of money. Read our disclaimer.

Brand

Harrison Spinks

4.6/5Owners269 reviews
Price range£455 – £1,534
Brand

Dormeo

Our pick
5.0/5Owners1 review
Price range£600 – £700

On aggregated owner reviews, Dormeo scores higher: 5.0 against 4.6 out of 5.

Becky’s take

By Becky Reeve

Checked against current models and prices in October 2026

Harrison Spinks is the better mattress at every firmness the two brands share. Harrison Spinks is a Leeds family firm making pocket-sprung mattresses with natural fillings, some of them grown on its own farm, and they still feel right years on. Dormeo is three boxed hybrids with memory foam on top, and almost nobody has reviewed one yet.

Foam or no foam is the choice. Harrison Spinks has no foam anywhere. Wool sits above springs that move one at a time, so nothing on top sinks and warms around you. The Grassington is the medium-firm to compare with Dormeo's Octasmart Hybrid, the Collingham is the medium to compare with the Octasmart Plus, and the Alwoodley is the soft-medium to compare with the Octasmart Deluxe. At each firmness I'd take the one made in Yorkshire.

Dormeo's one argument is the memory foam. If you share with someone who turns all night and you wake each time, foam deadens that and wool doesn't. If so, buy the Octasmart Plus. Everyone else should buy the Harrison Spinks. Harrison Spinks' dearer models cost more than any Dormeo, so be sure you'll keep it ten years before you pay.

Head to head

Both ranges are sprung throughout, so the difference is in the comfort layers on top and in price. Harrison Spinks runs from soft-medium to firm, and Dormeo runs from soft-medium to medium-firm. Harrison Spinks is the cheaper way in, though not by much. But at the top end Harrison Spinks goes further, so it also has the more premium options. Harrison Spinks's owner score rests on far more reviews (269 against 1), so treat Dormeo's number as the less settled of the two.

How they differ

Harrison SpinksDormeo
Mattresses we list153
Price range£455 – £1,534£600 – £700
Owner rating
4.6/5Owners269 reviews
5.0/5Owners1 review

Mattresses only. Owner ratings are the review-weighted average across each brand’s mattresses on UK retailer sites. Prices read 28 October 2026.

Harrison Spinks

Harrison Spinks is a generational family business that has captured the spirit of the entire hand-made portion of the industry thanks to their traditional materials and handcrafting excellence. The range is of a much higher quality than many competing brands and as a result the price point is typically found within the higher-end but the result is a bespoke nights sleep that will ooze excellence.

Dormeo

Dormeo first popped up on our radar back in the early 2000’s, finding different avenues to market than traditional with their frequent TV advertising and push toward their own independent store over the conventional retailer derived market. Dormeo typically sells mid to high range products.

Regardless of your budget, there’s likely to be something suitable for a reasonable price point.

Harrison Spinks owner satisfaction

Owners are mostly very happy with this brand which is quite impressive given the price point. Typically we find that when the price of mattresses starts to lead toward the high-end, customers' expectations can sometimes be distorted which results in a less-favourable experience. Thankfully that is mostly not the case here. Owners who bring up the price more often accept it than not, "A bit pricey but the quality reflects the price" as one wrote, though a few didn't think it was worth it, one calling theirs "nothing special for the price I paid". The natural fillings are a reason several give for buying. They can smell at first. That faded within days or weeks for some, but one owner said theirs "smells like a barn". Back pain gets mentioned both ways, with more owners saying theirs has eased than saying the mattress left them aching.

Harrison Spinks supportiveness

The support materials utilised in all Harrison Spinks products is a reliable pocket spring base layer. Pocket springs continue to be the best option for support, offering measured and reliable body contouring across the entire mattress and featuring edge to edge even support and roll together prevention.

Firmness within the range varies but has a pivot toward medium and medium firm tension mattresses all of which are made from luxurious materials and hand made in the UK. Interestingly, Harrison Spinks is the partner of choice for many of the sub-brands sold throughout the popular retailer. The result of this is a Flaxby & Feather and Black sub-division of quality mattresses that will be of equal interest to those looking for a good quality and highly rewarding nights sleep.

Harrison Spinks durability

I think the most important stat when it comes to durability is around the warranty and guarantee periods. After all, if the manufacturer doesn’t believe in their product, why would you? Thankfully you get a 5 year guarantee at minimum across the majority of products on show which comes fairly close to the average replacement period of 7 years for the industry as a whole.

Durability generally doesn’t look to be a concern going by the compounds used. In the reviews, several owners are repeat buyers, one writing “Had a Harrison before and very good for years hence why bought again”, while a small number say theirs softened or dipped within weeks or months.

Harrison Spinks best offers

We've managed to find the following top deals from across the web on Harrison Spinks mattresses.

  • Up to 55% Off Sale

Dormeo owner satisfaction

One owner of the Octasmart Premium Hybrid Plus, four weeks in, reported "slowly seeing an improvement in my sleep and feeling better rested".

Dormeo supportiveness

Traditionally we judge a mattress manufacturer's support by the layer denoted to it and in the case of Dormeo this looks to be primarily pocket springs as a base layer. Pocket springs are market leading and outperform equivalent open coil and reflex foam units, they achieve this by having better body contouring, less settlement issues and better durability.

Dormeo durability

The Octasmart Premium Hybrids at Bensons for Beds carry a 5 year guarantee, and Dormeo quotes longer warranties on its own site (both checked October 2026). This is important because without a warranty you will be unprotected in the years that follow.

Dormeo best offers

We've managed to find the following top deals from across the web on Dormeo mattresses.

  • Offers on Dormeo

Owner reviews of Harrison Spinks mattresses

5 Johnh

I have had this mattress for 5 weeks now. When I first unpacked it, there was a slight smell for a day, but since then it hasn't smelt at all. (It smelt of canvas which I found quite pleasant actually!) It feels nice and soft each night when you first get on it, but then can feel it supporting you. I guess this is what is meant by a medium-firm mattress. (My old mattress was over 20 yrs old; if anything it would have been rated as very firm!) I have had no problem sleeping with this mattress, no aches or pains when waking up. It is recommended to rotate the mattress once per week for 12 weeks, so I am still doing that. It is easy to do using the handles on the side of the mattress. No depressions in the mattress have appeared, and it still feels just like new. Although we have already had both hot nights and cold ones, I have never felt too hot or cold due to the mattress (obviously the duvet used is also going to make a difference). Overall I am extremely satisfied with the mattress, and with mattressonline.

4 Helen

To be perfectly honest, I'm not convinced but I think the problem is me, not the product. The mattress is clearly very good quality, but it's a lot firmer than I was hoping for and expecting from the soft/medium description. On the spare bed, which is a fully sprung base, it works reasonably well, which is why I haven't yet engaged the 60 day return option, but on the bed I ordered it for originally, which is a solid Ottoman base, it is way too hard. I'm sure that with use it will soften up, but it's still way too hard for me personally to sleep on comfortably and I doubt it will ever be that soft. Indeed, in desperation I ended up going to a shop and buying a much cheaper (and far inferior quality), softer mattress because I simply couldn't do 30 days sleeping on that mattress. I am going to contact Mattress Online today and enquire about swapping it for something softer.

4 Dave

Good Points: Quality is obvious. If we hadn't had a tempur for over ten years, I would say this is a really comfy bed and would be happy for its life time use. Albeit, only five years gauranteed! Having had a tempur though, I would probably revert back. Mainly due to spouse requiring that extra softness and a complete awareness removal from any turn/roll movement by partner. While this is a fantastic make and constructed with the Best Materials, we have been served well with the tempur and too be honest, can say, there aren't any regrets with the purchase. Improvement Points: Comparing this to our tempur, it would be difficult to separate, based on the very different structures. That said, a longer guarantee period would be an advantage. Price for price - this would be a distinct advantage.

2 John

We tried the mattress in the shop and picked it over the medium/firm version. However when the mattress was delivered it was so firm it caused my partner hip pain. We contacted mattress inline via the 60 day sleep guarantee and they swapped it next day. The service was 5* and reason we buy all our mattresses via them. The new mattress is the medium firm and is super comfy even after the first night. Makes me think the first was faulty it was that hard and nothing like the shop one we tried.

1 Nigel K

The mattress smells like a farmyard, not natural, and has made our bedding smell as well as the bedroom. This is not the natural smell the company claims, there is something wrong with the mattress. We cannot have the mattress removed from our home or changed for another month as the company wants to send somebody to check the mattress, but they cannot visit us for the next four weeks. Do not ever buy a mattress from Harrison Spinks unless you enjoy your bedroom and bed linen smelling like you are sleeping in a barn on a farm.

Owner reviews of Dormeo mattresses

5 Sandra D

So far (4wks in) it's been good, I'm slowly seeing an improvement in my sleep and feeling better rested. May it continue

This website uses cookies to give you the best experience.We use cookies. Cookie policy