Why our sleep experts loved it
If you're on the hunt for a proper, proper orthopaedic style mattress that doesn't give an inch under you, the Hypnos Honley Extra Firm is 100% in that lane. In my testing, it was immediately, unapologetically firm; the kind of surface you notice the second you lie down because there is very little sink and very little cushioning softness.
That will be exactly what a small number of people want, and in particular dedicated back sleepers who like to feel held in a straight, level line. But I will be blunt, I found it too firm for my body type, and I think it will be too firm for most people, and especially anyone who needs noticeable pressure relief at the shoulder and hip.
Construction & Materials This is a pocket sprung mattress built around 1000 Hypnos ReActivePro springs, with three outer rows of firmer gauge springs to bolster the edges. It is finished with a hand side-stitched border, tufted surface, and a breathable viscose cover.
Comfort-wise, the headline is wool, plus cotton and soft white fibres. The description also mentions two layers of a polyester and cotton blend (aimed at airflow and moisture wicking) and eOlus fibres from recycled materials. Together, these create a firmer, more resistant comfort layer than you would get on a medium or even a standard firm mattress.
It is also a tall mattress at 30cm deep, which is worth clocking if you use fitted sheets that come up tight, or if your bed frame has a lower footboard and you prefer the mattress to sit a little less proud.
Firmness & Feel The feel is best described as “on top” rather than “in”. When I lay on my back, I could feel the mattress working to keep my spine straight, with a stable, almost board-like steadiness under my pelvis and lower back. That is the sensation extra-firm fans chase, and the Honley delivers it without hesitation.
On my side, though, it was a different story. Because there is so little give, my shoulder and hip did not nestle in, and that translated to pressure building quite quickly. If you are a side sleeper, or you only occasionally sleep on your side, I would be very cautious, it is not a forgiving surface.
Performance & Support Support is the Honley's strongest suit. The pocket springs respond independently, and the edge design gives a secure, planted feel when sitting on the side or sleeping nearer the edge. If you like a mattress that does not collapse when you move around, this is built for that.
In practice, I found it steady and calm rather than bouncy, with a controlled response when changing position. That is usually what you want from a premium pocket-sprung build, and it suits sleepers who prefer a stable platform.
Temperature Regulation Temperature control should suit most people. Wool is naturally breathable and helps buffer temperature swings, and the blended fibre layers are pitched as airflow and moisture-wicking. In my experience, the overall feel is more “dry and stable” than “snuggly and sink-in”, which tends to sleep fairly neutral.
Practical Features You get a 60-night comfort trial (with a 30-night minimum before swapping) and a 10-year guarantee, which takes the sting out of choosing something this firm online. Pricing starts from £1,119.95, and delivery is listed as 4 to 6 weeks.
It is described as single-sided, which means you rotate rather than flip. One small oddity is that some of the on-page wording can look contradictory, so I would treat it as rotate-only unless the retailer confirms otherwise in writing.
Pros Genuinely extra-firm, orthopaedic-style support for people who actively want a very firm surface 1000 ReActivePro pocket springs deliver structured, even support and a controlled feel when moving Strong edge stability from the firmer outer spring rows and reinforced border, useful if you sit on the side of the bed a lot Wool and breathable fibre layers should help with temperature regulation and a fresher feel across seasons 60-night comfort trial and 10-year guarantee add reassurance for such a decisive firmness choice Cons Too firm for most people, and particularly unforgiving for side sleepers at the shoulder and hip Premium price, so it only feels worth it if you truly need this level of firmness Some mixed messaging around single-sided vs double-sided care, so it is worth double-checking expectations Who It Suits Dedicated back sleepers who feel best on a very firm, flat surface and want strong spinal alignment support.
People seeking an orthopaedic feel , including some sleepers managing back discomfort, provided they genuinely like, and benefit from, a very firm mattress rather than a pressure-relieving one.
Anyone who prioritises stability and edge support , especially if you tend to use the full width of the mattress.
Who It Doesn't Suit Most side sleepers , particularly lighter to average builds who need the mattress to flex at the shoulder and hip for comfort.
Anyone who likes cushioning or a bit of sink , because the Honley stays very “on the surface” and does not soften into that enveloping feel.
Combination sleepers who rotate onto their side in the night, as the firmness can make side sleeping feel restless.
Final Verdict The Hypnos Honley Extra Firm is not a safe, middle-of-the-road buy, it is a specialist-feeling mattress with a clear mission. In my testing it felt too firm and, on my side, genuinely uncomfortable, but I can also see it being a very satisfying choice for the right person, a committed back sleeper who wants that firm, orthopaedic steadiness and does not want their mattress to give much at all.
My advice is simple: only go for it if you already know you like extra-firm mattresses, and if you do, the 60-night comfort trial is the key practical safety net. Otherwise, most people will be better served by something a step or two softer that still supports the spine but offers more pressure relief.
Why you can trust WantMattress
We spend hours testing (and/or researching) every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about
how we test .
