A hard bed for a sore back is the advice that sends many people looking for a mattress like this, usually with a wish for something traditional that won't stretch the budget. On paper the Highgrove Solar Ortho Dream is that bed: an extra firm, hand-tufted, double-sided mattress from Highgrove, sold at Archers Sleep Centre. It sits a grade above the firm Highgrove Solar Luxury Dream and right beside the Highgrove Solar Orthopocket 1500. Everything in it is built to keep a body up on the surface, from the nylon tapes pulled tight through the fillings to a spring unit wired together from head to foot.
That spring unit is the difference from the Orthopocket, and it decides the buy: Bonnell coils tied to one another by a spiral wire work as one piece, where the Orthopocket's small pocket springs each move alone, so a partner's turning crosses this bed and stays put on that one. This is a mattress for a narrow group: somebody heavy who sleeps alone on their back or front and already knows a very hard mattress suits them. Side sleepers, couples, anyone of average build or lighter, and anyone furnishing a spare room should walk past it: a guest could be any weight and any shape, and extra firm suits the narrowest spread of bodies there is. If you came in set on this one, I'm going to try to talk you out of it, because extra firm is a specialist grade that suits few bodies and an open coil is the wrong way to build it.
On the Ortho Dream, Ortho means pre-tensioned tufting over wired coils
The name here means extra firm, and part of that firmness comes from the tufting. Nylon tapes are passed right through the mattress at intervals and tied off with a cotton tuft on each face. Archers says this "pre-tensions the mattress to provide a firmer sleeping surface" and keeps the fillings where they belong.
Underneath are rows of hourglass Bonnell coils, each joined to its neighbours top and bottom by a helical wire running the length of the mattress. The fillings are white fibre in several layers, tufted flat on both faces, with no pillow top or box top above them. Pressure at one point draws in the coils around it, which leaves a shoulder or a hip very little room to go in. It's 27cm (about 10.6in) deep.
Is the Ortho Dream too firm? For most bodies, yes
For most people it is. How heavy you are comes before how you lie, for me, and an extra firm needs both to line up. My own rule of thumb moves you up a grade once you're past about eighteen stone, and extra firm is the top of the scale, so that's roughly where this bed starts to make sense for a back or front sleeper. A light sleeper barely registers on a grade this hard.
Side sleeping is where it goes wrong fastest. On your side, your weight goes through one shoulder and one hip, and a pre-tensioned top over linked coils won't let either go in far enough to keep your spine level, so the pressure stays parked on those two points. I sleep on my side, which puts me near the front of the queue of people I'd keep off it.
If a sore back is the reason you're shopping, start somewhere else entirely. "Firmer is better for your back" sends more people home with the wrong bed than any other piece of shop-floor advice, and a medium firm is the place to begin.
Owners who wanted hard are happy, and one report would put me off
The owners who bought it because they wanted a hard bed are pleased with it, and plenty call it firm and good value. One puts the surface well: "the slight scrunch feel on top makes it feel more natural".
The firmness complaint that does turn up runs the opposite way to what you'd guess: some owners found it softer than extra firm. I believe owners over a label, and on a bed you'd buy only for its hardness, softer than promised undoes the reason to own it.
One middling review counts for more. Within a couple of weeks a buyer reported sagging in places, tufting buttons working loose and the sides already soft. Hers was a zip-and-link pair, so it's one report about two mattresses joined together, but on a bed bought purely to stay hard, early sagging would put me off.
It flips as well as rotates, and turning it is a two-person job
Both faces are tufted to sleep on, so the Ortho Dream goes over as well as round, and sleeping on both sides spreads the wear. One owner has had theirs for years and turned it round to get more out of it.
No turning handles are listed for it, so plan on two people taking hold of the border and walking it over, and ask Archers for the turning instructions when you order.
The exchange only works with Archers' protector on it
Archers will swap a mattress you don't get on with, once, on its own terms: a Purecare protector on the same order and used the whole time, several weeks' sleep before you're allowed to ask and a short window after that, redelivery charged, nothing back for swapping down, and UK mainland addresses only. Order the protector with the bed.
Highgrove's own warranty terms tie its longer cover to an approved base bought at the same time as the mattress. If you're buying the mattress without a base, ask Archers how that applies first.
Buy the Orthopocket 1500, or a Highgrove one grade softer
If you know you need extra firm, buy the Highgrove Solar Orthopocket 1500. Highgrove makes it too, a double-sided, hand-tufted extra firm that Archers sells alongside this one, built on small-diameter pocket springs in place of the wired coil. It's 29cm deep to this one's 27cm, with turning handles on the border. Archers gives it a longer warranty as well.
If you only think you need extra firm, take the Highgrove Solar Pocket 1000. It's a turnable pocket-sprung bed graded firm, which is plenty for a back sleeper of ordinary weight. Its thousand springs is a light count for my taste, and it still beats any open coil as a bed for every night.
Kitting out a spare room on very little money? Choose the Highgrove Solar Luxury Dream, a firm open coil that far more of the people who stay over can sleep on.