Why our sleep experts loved it
The Shire Manhattan Memory Mattress in a Box is one of those budget friendly, British made mattresses that looks appealing on paper. It is vacuum packed for easy delivery, wrapped in a soft knitted stretch cover, and topped with a thin layer of memory foam for that initial cosy feel. I have not been able to view this one in person, Archers is up in Scotland, so this review is based on the listed specs and the customer feedback available, not an at home trial.
Design and features
Shire has kept things simple. You are getting a traditional open coil spring unit, listed as 12.5 gauge, with 10mm of memory foam under the cover. The fabric sounds like a step up from the most basic budget tickings, and the contrasting border is a nice touch for a mattress that is clearly trying to compete on value.
My issue is the support core. Open coil can work, but it is the weak link in the Manhattan. It is robust, yes, but it tends to behave like one big springy raft rather than lots of individual points of support. That usually means less contouring, more pressure build up at shoulders and hips, and a higher chance of feeling the structure over time. One customer even mentioned feeling the fasteners that hold the springs, which is exactly the sort of thing that can happen when comfort layers are thin and the build is more old school.
Mattress comfort
That 10mm memory foam layer is probably the best part of this mattress. It is enough to take the edge off, give a slightly smoother surface feel, and reduce a bit of movement. But it is not enough to deliver the deep, slow melting hug people associate with true memory foam beds. A reviewer saying they cannot feel the memory foam does not surprise me, because 10mm is more of a comfort seasoning than a main ingredient.
Comfort feedback is quite consistent overall. Several buyers call it firm or comfortably firm, and one person says it has helped their back pain massively. Another says they ordered firm and it arrived more medium than expected, so do not assume the tension will feel identical for every body type. In my experience, open coil mattresses can feel firmer at first and then become less supportive as the top settles and the springs do what open coils tend to do over time.
Suitability
This medium tension is generally a decent match for side sleepers, especially average weight sleepers who want a little give at the shoulder without sinking too far. Back sleepers can also get on with it, but if you are buying specifically for lumbar support, I would normally push you toward something firmer or a pocket sprung support system that holds the waist more precisely.
For heavier bodies, or anyone who is sensitive to pressure points, I am sceptical. The combination of open coil and a thin memory foam layer often struggles to keep alignment tidy long term. And if you share a bed, do not expect brilliant motion isolation. Open coil is not the quiet, independent support you get from pocket springs.
The verdict
The Manhattan feels like a classic compromise mattress. The memory foam layer is genuinely nice for day to day comfort, the cover sounds pleasant, and the box delivery format is practical. But the open coil core is the limitation that you cannot ignore. If your budget is tight, you could do worse, and plenty of customers seem happy for the money. But if you can stretch even a little, I would rather see you in an entry level pocket spring mattress with a similar comfort layer. You will usually get better contouring, better partner comfort, and a more convincing support story over the years.
Why you can trust WantMattress
We spend hours testing (and/or researching) every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about
how we test .
