Why our sleep experts loved it
The Shire Roma Orthopaedic Mattress is a straightforward, old-school firm mattress aimed at shoppers who want solid support, sensible pricing, and a build that is easy to live with. I should be upfront that my assessment here is spec-led only. I have not tested this mattress in store or at home, and I did not have the opportunity to pop into Archers in Scotland to try it in person. So this is based on construction details, brand patterns I’ve seen over the years, and what customers tend to report with this type of design.
Design and features
At heart, the Roma is an open coil mattress built around a 12.5 gauge spring unit. That tells you the intent right away. It is designed to feel firm and “held up”, rather than plush and contouring. You also get a soft knitted stretch fabric cover, which should feel nicer against the body than the cheaper, flatter damask covers often used at this end of the market. The fillings are described as hypo-allergenic white fibre, which is a practical choice for keeping the surface feeling cleaner and fresher, but it is not the same thing as having a proper pressure-relieving comfort layer.
There is rod-edge reinforcement around the perimeter, which sounds reassuring on paper. In practice, open coil mattresses still tend to be weak at the edges compared with pocket spring or foam perimeter builds. This is one of my main hesitations with the Roma. If you sit on the side of the bed to put your socks on, or if you sleep close to the edge, I’d expect that “roll-off” sensation sooner than you’d get with a better-supported design.
Mattress comfort
The comfort story here is firm support first, cushioning second. The fibre fillings can add a little initial softness, and the knitted cover should stop it feeling too stark, but you are still sleeping over a single, linked spring unit that distributes load across the surface. That can feel stable and familiar, and for some people it is exactly what they want. But if you are hoping for any meaningful sink around the shoulders or hips, I don’t think this is the right pick.
One genuine plus is that it is double sided. The brand recommends rotating top to toe and flipping it, and that matters. It gives you a fighting chance of extending comfort life, especially compared with many budget one-sided mattresses that dip early. A customer review mentioning it “lasts a long time” fits that expectation, and another calling it “firm orthopaedic” is consistent with what the spec suggests.
Suitability
This firmness will suit back sleepers best, and some front sleepers who like a flatter, firmer feel. If you sleep on your side, especially with a more pronounced hip and shoulder shape, I think this will be uncomfortable for a lot of people. Side sleeping usually needs extra give in the comfort layer so the spine can stay level. A firm open coil with fibre comfort tends to push back rather than yield, and that can lead to pressure points.
For smaller rooms, the Roma being a simple, turnable mattress can be a practical buy. One reviewer called it excellent for a small room, and that reads to me like a guest room or box room solution where you want something supportive, not fussy, and not too expensive.
The verdict
I like that the Shire Roma keeps things honest. It is firm, it is double sided, and it should represent decent value if you specifically want a traditional orthopaedic feel. But I’m not going to pretend I’m excited by the open coil core. Edge support is typically a weak point, and once you factor that in, I think there are better options at similar money, particularly mattresses with a reflex foam support layer or a more modern hybrid approach. If you are a committed back sleeper on a budget and you will actually flip it regularly, it can make sense. If you want better edge stability, more pressure relief, or a more premium feel, I’d personally look elsewhere.
Why you can trust WantMattress
We spend hours testing (and/or researching) every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about
how we test .
