Why our sleep experts loved it
The Sealy Edendale Backcare Support Firm is a traditional, old school type of mattress. It has a no nonsense open coil construction, and its marketing is aimed squarely at those who want proper back support rather than a soft, sink in feel.
Its in the middle of Sealy’s price bracket at Bensons, and is often heavily discounted, so while the price still feels a little toppy for what is, at heart, a fairly vanilla Sealy, it’s not especially high for a branded, firm support mattress.
In use, it feels very much like it sounds. Firm, supportive and reassuringly solid under the spine. This is not a hotel style mattress with lavish natural fillings or a deeply cushioned, cloud like pillow top. The ReNew eco fibres and fairly standard damask cover are a lot more practical and serviceable, but they don’t exactly shout premium when you first get in.
That said, Sealy has a solid track record when it comes to durability, and the Edendale has all the basic building blocks in place to be a long lasting, reliable bed, especially for back sleepers in particular. The trade off is simple: you’re paying for support and longevity more than you are for outright plush comfort.
Construction & Materials The key piece of engineering in the Sealy Edendale Backcare Support Firm is Sealy’s PostureTech Core Support spring system, which is an open coil unit that has been designed to firm up as pressure is applied. Put simply, the springs compress more under your heaviest areas and give a bit more under the lighter sections, which helps to level out the body rather than letting you hammock in the middle.
Above that is a layer of comfort made from Sealy’s ReNew fibres. These are synthetic eco fibres that are created from recycled plastics, and have been designed to boost airflow and add a touch of cushioning without the heat build up you sometimes get with dense foams. It’s a practical, eco minded choice, but if you are used to wool, cotton or other natural blends, you will probably find the surface feels more utilitarian than luxurious.
A Belgian style damask cover wraps everything up, and this has been treated with an anti allergy finish that is designed to help keep allergens at bay over the life of the mattress. For anyone with dust or mite sensitivities that’s a genuinely useful touch, especially if you combine it with a good mattress protector.
The mattress is hand tufted, which tacks down the fillings and keeps the whole structure taut. It contributes directly to the firm feel, because tufting pulls the surface fabric down into the spring unit, reducing loft but increasing stability. Around the perimeter there is a reinforced border, which makes the edge feel noticeably sturdier and helps keep the sleeping surface usable right up to the sides of the bed.
Overall depth is around the mid twenties in centimetres, which is perfectly respectable but not especially deep by modern standards, especially at this price. It should fit standard fitted sheets easily, but if you are coming from a very chunky pillow top or hybrid, the Edendale will probably look and feel a little slimmer and more pared back.
Firmness & Feel This version of the Edendale is rated firm, and that rating is accurate. On first getting in, the surface feels tight, flat and supportive with very little initial sink. The combination of hand tufting and open coil springs means you are always aware of a solid, underlying structure even once the top fibres have warmed up.
For back sleepers that can be exactly what you want. The mattress prevents the pelvis from dropping and encourages a neutral spine position particularly if you are of average to heavier build. There is enough fibre on top to stop it feeling like a board, but it never strays into cushioned or plush territory.
On your side, things get more divisive. The firm tension does not offer a huge amount of contouring around the shoulders and hips, especially if you are lighter framed. Over time the ReNew fibres will compress slightly and the springs will relax a little, but this remains a decidedly firm sleep surface. In practice, I would say it really only suits committed back sleepers and those who need extra back and neck support while on their back. Most side sleepers will find it a bit unforgiving after a full night.
There is a mild, traditional bounce from the open coil unit. You can feel the mattress responding as you move across it, but it is not overly springy or unstable. It feels more like a classic old school orthopaedic mattress than a modern, cocooning hybrid.
Performance & Support This is where the Edendale Backcare Support Firm earns its keep. The spring system does a good job of keeping the body on a single, even plane, with the central third feeling a touch more robust, which is perfect for the lumbar region. Back sleepers with niggling lower back issues will likely appreciate how little the pelvis is allowed to sag.
Heavier sleepers, particularly those on the taller or broader side, will probably also find the firmness reassuring. The springs have enough resistance to prevent you from bottoming out, and the reinforced border helps when you sit to get dressed or sleep close to the edge. There is minimal sensation of roll off, and the usable area feels genuinely full width.
Where the Edendale is less convincing is in the pressure relief and motion isolation. As an open coil mattress with a firmer tension, you do not get the tailored, independent support or pressure relief you would from a good pocket sprung mattress at a similar price point. If one partner moves a lot, the other will feel some of that movement and lighter side sleepers in particular may notice pressure through the shoulders and hips on longer nights.
That said, the mattress feels robust and stable. There is no excessive flex when you sit on the edge, no obvious soft spots and the hand tufting helps to maintain a uniform feel right across the surface. Sealy’s reputation for durable spring units backs up the sense that this is built to go the distance rather than to impress on day one and sag quickly.
Temperature Regulation One of the Edendale’s quiet strengths is temperature control. There is no thick slab of memory foam or dense foam pillow top, just an airy open coil spring unit with breathable synthetic fibres on top. Air can move fairly freely through the springs and through the ReNew layer, which helps to carry heat away during the night.
The damask cover, while not particularly plush, does feel cool to the touch and allows the mattress to breathe. Combined with the relatively modest depth and firm, non sinking feel, this makes the Edendale a good choice for hot sleepers or anyone who finds deeper, foam heavy mattresses stifling.
If you are very cold natured and like a mattress that hugs and insulates you, it will not deliver that cosy, enveloping warmth. It tends to keep you more on top of the bed rather than in it, which naturally feels cooler.
Practical Features The Sealy Edendale Backcare Support Firm is a non turn mattress, which means you only need to rotate it head to toe periodically rather than flipping it. That’s helpful because, while not the heaviest mattress in the world, a fully sprung mattress of this depth is not something most people enjoy turning regularly.
Handles are typically provided on this style of Sealy mattress, which makes rotation a bit easier, but you will still want two people to manoeuvre it safely. Once in place, the firm structure means it will sit neatly on a divan base or a solid slatted frame without too much dipping between the slats as long as they are sensibly spaced.
Retailers will usually include a multi year guarantee and, in some cases, a comfort trial which gives you a small safety net if the feel proves too firm or not supportive enough once you are sleeping on it every night. You will almost always be advised to use a mattress protector to keep that guarantee intact, which is a sensible idea regardless.
Who It Suits Back sleepers who like a firmer feel are, unsurprisingly, the happiest on this mattress. The Edendale keeps the spine well aligned, prevents the mid section sinking and gives that slightly braced, orthopaedic feel that some backs genuinely respond well to.
Heavier sleepers who prefer traditional support should also get on with it. The open coil unit and firm tension provides a consistent, unyielding platform that resists hammocking particularly if you are sharing a bed and need the centre to stay strong over time.
Hot sleepers and those who dislike foam will appreciate the cooler, more breathable construction and the fact that there is no deep memory foam layer to trap heat or make it harder to move around at night.
Allergy sufferers may find the treated damask cover a meaningful bonus, especially in combination with the easy care, rotate only design, which makes it simpler to keep the surface fresh.
Guest rooms or occasional use beds could be another good match. The Edendale has the robustness and everyday practicality you want for a spare room, and the firm feel will suit a wider range of occasional guests than something ultra soft would.
Who It Doesn't Suit Most side sleepers are unlikely to be fully comfortable here. The firm tension and relatively modest top layer means the shoulders and hips do not sink deeply enough, which can translate into pressure points and numbness by the early hours, particularly if you are lighter or have bony joints.
Lighter weight sleepers of any position may find the surface simply too unyielding. If you are on the lighter side, the springs and tufts do not engage as much, so you are likely to feel perched on top rather than properly cradled.
Couples sensitive to movement should approach with caution. As with most open coil mattresses, there is a degree of partner disturbance. If one of you tosses and turns the other will feel some movement because all the coils are linked.
Anyone chasing a truly luxurious feel will probably be underwhelmed. The ReNew fibres, modest depth and standard damask cover are perfectly adequate but they do not deliver the plush, high end finish you can find in better pocket sprung or hybrid options at a similar money.
Final Verdict The Sealy Edendale Backcare Support Firm is in many ways, a classic Sealy mattress: solid, sensible and built to last, with a firm, back focused feel. The open coil spring unit, reinforced edge and eco fibre comfort layer make it a dependable choice if your priorities are spinal alignment, cooling and durability rather than cloud like softness.
Price wise, it is in a slightly awkward spot. It can feel a little toppy for a fairly simple open coil specification with synthetic fibres, although regular promotions bring it back into more reasonable territory. You are not being ripped off, but you also are not getting the sort of rich specification that would make this feel like a bargain.
For dedicated back sleepers who know they need a firm, no frills bed and who trust Sealy’s reputation for reliability, the Edendale Backcare Support Firm is a perfectly sound choice that should see you through many years of use. It feels honest, workmanlike and reassuringly sturdy.
If, however, you want more obvious comfort, deeper cushioning or better motion isolation you can probably do a little better in this price bracket by looking at a good pocket sprung or hybrid design with more sophisticated comfort layers. In short, this is a fine mattress and a reliable one, but its appeal is firmly to those who put support and durability ahead of luxurious feel.
Why you can trust WantMattress
We spend hours testing (and/or researching) every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about
how we test .
