Back sleepers sent off to find a firm mattress often end up lying on the Evesham 3000 in a Dreams shop, some of them straight from a session on the store's Sleepmatch scanner. It's a firm mattress from Dream Team, the own-label range Dreams created as Team GB's official sleep partner, and it's built from two layers of pocket springs with a cooling foam called DreamTex and a deep, quilted pillow top sewn over them. The idea is a firm bed that doesn't feel hard. It sits in the middle of the range, priced alongside the turnable Dream Team Frome 4200 Pocket Wool. Lie back on it and you sink into soft quilting first, then meet springs that push straight back. Our tester, a back sleeper, came away very happy with it.
In a Dreams store they lay on it face up, their usual position at home, at just over ten and a half stone. The core felt firm and springy under them, and the deep top added a plush layer without taking any of that firmness away. The contrast was what they liked best, a sturdy middle under a softer surface, and the whole bed felt noticeably cool to lie on. For back sleeping they couldn't fault it.
Back sleepers of average weight and above are who it's for, along with front sleepers who need their hips kept level. Couples who both sleep that way do well on it too, because owners keep saying they barely feel each other turn over. If you sleep on your side and weigh under roughly nine stone, walk past it: your shoulder flattens the quilting and ends up on firm springs, and you'll wake with the ache to prove it.
I'd still send most people to the Frome. A pillow top is the part of a mattress I least want to pay for, and on a bed you can't turn over it's the part you're stuck with. For much the same money the Frome gives you the same Firm grade with wool inside, more springs and two sides to sleep on.
Owners with bad backs love it, and I can see why
Give the Evesham its due first. Quilting over firm springs is a clever way to make a hard bed kind on the first night, and the owners show it working. The happiest of them are back sleepers who came into the shop with a sore back, were matched to this bed there and bought it in a sale. They write about getting up without the stiffness they used to wake with, and one owner put the balance neatly: firm enough for their back, yet "soft enough that it doesn't feel like sleeping on the ground".
When owners grumble about the feel, it's that it's harder than they expected, and I couldn't find one calling it soft. So believe the Firm label, and if anything read it as firm with a soft layer on top. Dreams' own scale runs two steps harder than Firm, which makes the label a fair picture of this bed: firm, not rock hard.
What I won't do is take those happy backs as proof that a firmer bed is better for a back. That idea is the most expensive misunderstanding in mattress buying. These owners sleep face up, where a firm bed keeps an average-weight back sleeper's spine level, and that narrow reason is why it works for them. Medium firm is still where I'd start almost anybody who doesn't know what they want.
Dreams sells the same springs without the top
Look at the Sophie Conran Nest Pocket Wool Mattress, also at Dreams. It uses the same spring unit, 2,738 springs in a double across the same pair of layers, micro springs over taller pocket springs, and it stands 22cm deep. The Nest puts British wool and a Platinum 3D fibre layer over those springs. The Evesham puts DreamTex and polyester there instead, then sews the pillow top over the lot, and that top is what takes it to 28cm. With the two beds at much the same price, the top is what your money goes on here.
Pillow tops sit on my avoid list, so let me give the maker its due before I say why. This top is generous and cool to the touch, and it's doing exactly what our tester and those owners liked. My worry is later on. Soft quilting packs down faster than springs wear, and it packs down in the shape of you. A two-sided mattress lets you flip to a fresh face while the other recovers, whereas this one has a single face, so the hollows you make are the hollows you keep, moved round by rotating and no further.
That makes the guarantee worth reading, and it's a short one, the same as across the whole Dream Team range. Ask Dreams, before you hand over any money, what depth of hollow it treats as a fault. The quilting is where one turns up first.
Count the springs in any size and you won't land on 3,000
The single has 1,810, the small double 2,492, the double 2,738, the king 3,170 and the super king 3,800. The 3000 on the label matches none of them, and the double falls a couple of hundred short.
Each count also lumps two kinds of spring together, a layer of small micro springs over the full-height pocket springs, with one figure given for both. Dreams sells the micro springs as reacting to the tiniest movement, and they do make the surface a touch livelier. I'd say they're mostly there to swell the count, though, and once a king passes about 1,500 springs I stop caring how high the number climbs. The Frome's 3,712 includes micro springs too, so I wouldn't buy that one for its count either. The wool and the second side are what I'd pay for.
Cool to lie on, though some owners still wake up hot
Cooling is the Evesham's big pitch. DreamTex is a foam Dreams says soaks up heat when you're warm and gives it back as you cool, with silver infused in it for freshness, and the knitted cover is cool to the touch. Our tester felt that coolness straight away, and plenty of owners say it keeps them comfortable through the night.
I rate the foam above the fabric. A cooling foam gets a mild nod from me. A cool-touch cover is mostly felt in the first few minutes, until your body warms it through. I don't wave cooling claims through, and some owners aren't convinced by this one. A couple who had gone down to the thinnest duvet they could buy still woke up hot, and their advice was blunt: "If you often get hot in the night this isn't the mattress for you."
My answer for a hot sleeper is springs with natural fillings, which points to the Frome again. As for the silver, I'd want the name of a test before I paid extra for germ-fighting foam.
Deep, heavy, and only one side to sleep on
At 28cm (11 inches) it's at the deep end of what a standard fitted sheet will stretch over, and one owner had to buy new sheets because the old ones wouldn't reach. Order deep-pocket sheets with the mattress. It's heavy as well, 42kg in a double and 55kg in a super king, and it arrives flat at full size. Dreams' staff advise against bending it to get it upstairs, so measure the stairs and landing first, then pay to have it carried to the bedroom.
For its first three months, swing it end to end once a week, and after that once a month does it, with two of you lifting. It's dull, and it's the one bit of care that pays off: an owner who found it too firm at first said it got better after a few turns round. Keep it on a slatted frame or another flat base, because it isn't made for an adjustable one.
There's only one grade, Firm, and nothing to take off if you go off the top, so Dreams' 100-Night Comfort Guarantee is the only exit if you've chosen wrong. Read its terms before you lean on it. It trades your bed for a different Dreams mattress instead of refunding you, and it only opens once you've had the Evesham a month. Collection costs extra, and a protector must have been on it from night one.
Take the Frome home and leave the pillow top behind
Buy the Dream Team Frome 4200 Pocket Wool Mattress. It's in the same Dream Team range at Dreams, sold in the same Firm grade at much the same price, and it carries 3,712 springs in a double, British wool under both faces and a second side, so you can flip it as the fillings settle. At 23cm, your ordinary fitted sheets still go on.
You do give up the pillow top, so the Frome feels firmer on the first night, and flipping a 40kg double is a job for two. With my own money, the Evesham stays in the shop and the Frome comes home. If that first week felt too hard, I'd add a wool topper I can lift off and wash, which is more than a pillow top will ever let me do.
If it's the cool surface that drew you to the Evesham and you don't need it this firm, look at the Dream Team Brookfield. It's tufted flat with wool on both faces and nothing sewn on top, and its Medium grade still lies firm enough for a back sleeper.